Homebuyers won 16 of 23 disputes with builders, and every one before a state commission
Homebuyers won 16 of 23 disputes with builders over a month, including every order passed by the Punjab, Chandigarh and Maharashtra state consumer commissions.
Key points
- Homebuyers won 16 of the 23 builder disputes counted (70%); builders won 3 and 4 were partly allowed.
- The homebuyer won all 3 orders at the Punjab State Commission, all 3 at the Chandigarh State Commission and both at the Maharashtra State Commission.
- The count covers consumer commission, K-REAT and court orders Oquilia reported between 22 October 2026 and 21 November 2026.
Homebuyers won 16 of the 23 disputes with builders that Oquilia reported over the month to 21 November 2026, or 70%. Builders won 3 (13%) and 4 more (17%) were partly allowed. The homebuyer won every one of the orders passed by the Punjab, Chandigarh and Maharashtra state consumer commissions, while the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) split its 6 orders evenly.
What we found
The outcome split is wide. Of the 23 orders counted, 16 went to the homebuyer, 4 were partly allowed and 3 went to the builder. Most of the money at stake sat on the homebuyers' side as well: of the 14 orders whose stories give a sum, the 11 that homebuyers won add up to Rs 6.29 crore, against Rs 59,638 in the one builder win with a stated amount.
The forum made the clearest difference. The Karnataka Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (K-REAT) passed 9 of the 23 orders, or 39%, the most of any forum. Homebuyers won 6 of those 9, 2 were partly allowed and the builder won 1. The NCDRC passed 6, or 26%. Homebuyers won 2 of them, builders won 2 and 2 were partly allowed.
The state commissions told a different story. The Punjab State Commission passed 3 orders and the homebuyer won all 3. The Chandigarh State Commission also passed 3, and the homebuyer won all 3 of those too. Both orders from the Maharashtra State Commission went to the homebuyer. Not one state commission order in the set went to a builder.
Among builders, 20 different names appear in 23 orders. Omaxe New Chandigarh Developers was the only builder with 3 orders, and the homebuyer won all 3. The promoters of Nitesh Caesars Palace in Bengaluru appear twice: one homebuyer won outright and the other's appeal was partly allowed. No other builder appears more than once.
The stated amounts total Rs 11.41 crore across 14 orders. The median is Rs 53.64 lakh, the smallest Rs 59,638 and the largest Rs 5 crore. The largest 3 were the Rs 5 crore a residents' society claimed from G.S. Promoters & Developers, the Rs 1.26 crore refund the NCDRC ordered from Universal Drinks, and the Rs 1,13,80,672 of loan money in the Cubatic Shimul Ventures appeal.
Several homebuyer wins turned on the same point: a builder's offer of possession did not end its liability for delay. The Punjab State Commission held that Omaxe New Chandigarh Developers' offer of possession without a completion certificate was not valid, and ordered 9% yearly interest for the delay. The Chandigarh State Commission held that an offer of an incomplete flat by the same builder was not valid possession either. In a separate order, it held that a paper offer of possession without statutory approvals did not discharge Sushma Buildtech's duty, and ordered a refund of Rs 62,77,598 with 12% annual interest.
Other wins turned on how a refund is worked out. The NCDRC held that money Universal Drinks paid the bank to close a home loan could not be cut from the buyer's refund of Rs 1,26,44,365.97. The Punjab State Commission rejected a Rs 15,21,060 pre-EMI interest deduction that ATS Estates had made from a refund. The Maharashtra State Commission held that MahaRERA timeline extensions do not by themselves take away a buyer's right to delay interest from Prajapati Developers. K-REAT held that HDFC must recover a home loan it paid directly to Cubatic Shimul Ventures from the builder, and must make no adverse entry in the homebuyer's credit report.
The builders' 3 wins came on narrower grounds. The NCDRC held that Lodha Developers' cancellation of a Worli flat and forfeiture of 10% of the price were within the agreement, because the buyer had defaulted on payments. It dismissed 2 complaints against G.A. Builder because the buyers had taken the same question to MahaRERA and MahaREAT, and it recorded no finding on the merits. K-REAT held that GST of Rs 59,638 on a cancelled booking with Goyal Hariyana Developers must be claimed from the tax authorities, not the builder.
The partly allowed orders cut both ways. K-REAT confirmed the agreed price of Rs 1,74,94,260 for a BVL Estates penthouse but set aside Rs 11,22,868 of delay interest. The NCDRC rejected a residents' society's Rs 5 crore claim against G.S. Promoters & Developers and awarded Rs 10 lakh for a land shortfall. It ordered Hero Realty to pay Mohali buyers 10.4% a year for late possession.
| Reported | Builder | Forum | Sum at stake | Outcome | Story |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21 Nov 2026 | Hero Realty | NCDRC | Not stated | Partly allowed | Story |
| 21 Nov 2026 | G.A. Builder | NCDRC | Not stated | Builder won | Story |
| 20 Nov 2026 | ATS Estates | Punjab State Commission | Rs 18.6 lakh | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 20 Nov 2026 | SBL Builders | Punjab State Commission | Rs 71,44,760 | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 19 Nov 2026 | Universal Drinks | NCDRC | Rs 1.26 crore | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 19 Nov 2026 | Prajapati Developers | Maharashtra State Commission | Rs 57.27 lakh | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 18 Nov 2026 | BVL Estates | K-REAT | Rs 11,22,868 | Partly allowed | Story |
| 13 Nov 2026 | Space Properties | K-REAT | Rs 7 lakh | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 12 Nov 2026 | Omaxe New Chandigarh Developers | Punjab State Commission | Not stated | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 11 Nov 2026 | Goyal Hariyana Developers | K-REAT | Rs 59,638 | Builder won | Story |
| 10 Nov 2026 | Rose Builders & Developers | Maharashtra State Commission | Rs 19 lakh | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 10 Nov 2026 | Pioneer Developers | NCDRC | Rs 50 lakh | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 4 Nov 2026 | Omaxe New Chandigarh Developers | Chandigarh State Commission | Not stated | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 3 Nov 2026 | Cubatic Shimul Ventures | K-REAT | Rs 1,13,80,672 | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 1 Nov 2026 | Sushma Buildtech | Chandigarh State Commission | Rs 62.78 lakh | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 31 Oct 2026 | Vijicon Properties | K-REAT | Rs 60,91,329 | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 31 Oct 2026 | Nitesh Caesars Palace | K-REAT | Not stated | Partly allowed | Story |
| 31 Oct 2026 | Nitesh Caesars Palace | K-REAT | Not stated | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 29 Oct 2026 | G.S. Promoters & Developers | NCDRC | Rs 5 crore | Partly allowed | Story |
| 25 Oct 2026 | Purvankara | K-REAT | Not stated | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 25 Oct 2026 | East North VVS Realty | K-REAT | Rs 42 lakh | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 24 Oct 2026 | Omaxe New Chandigarh Developers | Chandigarh State Commission | Not stated | Homebuyer won | Story |
| 22 Oct 2026 | Lodha Developers | NCDRC | Not stated | Builder won | Story |
What it means for you
The pattern shows that, in the orders counted, homebuyers who took a delay or refund dispute to a forum mostly came away with an order in their favour. It also shows the grounds on which buyers lost: a default on their own payments, the same dispute run before two forums at once, and a claim made against the wrong party.
A homebuyer with a dispute over a project can complain to the RERA authority of the state where the project is. Consumer complaints can be filed online on e-Daakhil, the consumer commissions' filing portal, which shows the status of each case. The National Consumer Helpline, on 1915, takes consumer grievances and explains how to raise them.
In the G.A. Builder order, the NCDRC held that buyers could not run the same issue before MahaRERA and the commission.
How we counted
Oquilia counted 23 stories it published between 22 October 2026 and 21 November 2026 on orders of a consumer commission, a RERA appellate tribunal or a court in a dispute between a homebuyer and a builder.
We searched Oquilia's archive for stories over the window that mention homebuyers, RERA, builders, possession or flats. Each story kept had to report a single order and link to the official document behind it. We left out stories about lenders and borrowers, bank auctions, insolvency resolution plans, disciplinary orders against insolvency professionals, criminal investigations against builders, explainers and market reports. We left out an order between a homeowner and a construction contractor whose story did not name the firm, and an order that closed a batch of homebuyer cases because insolvency resolution plans now govern them, since it did not decide a single dispute. Where 2 stories reported the same order, we kept the earlier one.
The residents' society complaint against G.S. Promoters & Developers is counted because the society brought it on behalf of the project's buyers. The 2 Nitesh Caesars Palace orders are counted separately because each concerned a different homebuyer and ended differently.
"Homebuyer won" means the forum ruled for the buyer on the question before it, including where it dismissed a builder's appeal, review or revision. "Builder won" means the forum dismissed the buyer's complaint or allowed the builder's appeal. "Partly allowed" means each side won part of what it asked for. The builder is named as the story names it, shortened only by dropping words such as "Limited". The sum at stake is the figure the story gives for the money in dispute, such as a refund, a claim or an award; where a story gives no such figure, the table says "Not stated" and the order is left out of the totals and the median. Percentages are rounded to the nearest whole number.
Limits
As with any count of this kind, this counts only orders Oquilia reported, not every order passed. Cases are counted by the date Oquilia published the story, not the date of the order. Outcomes can change on appeal, and several of the stories note that the order may be appealed. Figures are those the stories state, not amounts paid. The set is too small to rank any builder or forum. Oquilia has not reviewed the merits of any case.
Sources & Citations
- Order: Hero Realty (NCDRC), 21 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: G.A. Builder (NCDRC), 21 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: ATS Estates (Punjab State Commission), 20 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: SBL Builders (Punjab State Commission), 20 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: Universal Drinks (NCDRC), 19 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: Prajapati Developers (Maharashtra State Commission), 19 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: BVL Estates (K-REAT), 18 Nov 2026 — Karnataka RERA
- Order: Space Properties (K-REAT), 13 Nov 2026 — Karnataka RERA
- Order: Omaxe New Chandigarh Developers (Punjab State Commission), 12 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: Goyal Hariyana Developers (K-REAT), 11 Nov 2026 — Karnataka RERA
- Order: Rose Builders & Developers (Maharashtra State Commission), 10 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: Pioneer Developers (NCDRC), 10 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: Omaxe New Chandigarh Developers (Chandigarh State Commission), 4 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: Cubatic Shimul Ventures (K-REAT), 3 Nov 2026 — Karnataka RERA
- Order: Sushma Buildtech (Chandigarh State Commission), 1 Nov 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: Vijicon Properties (K-REAT), 31 Oct 2026 — Karnataka RERA
- Order: Nitesh Caesars Palace (K-REAT), 31 Oct 2026 — Karnataka RERA
- Order: Nitesh Caesars Palace (K-REAT), 31 Oct 2026 — Karnataka RERA
- Order: G.S. Promoters & Developers (NCDRC), 29 Oct 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: Purvankara (K-REAT), 25 Oct 2026 — Karnataka RERA
- Order: East North VVS Realty (K-REAT), 25 Oct 2026 — Karnataka RERA
- Order: Omaxe New Chandigarh Developers (Chandigarh State Commission), 24 Oct 2026 — Indian Kanoon
- Order: Lodha Developers (NCDRC), 22 Oct 2026 — Indian Kanoon