Punjab consumer commission tells ATS Estates to pay homebuyers Rs 18.6 lakh balance
The Punjab State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission held that ATS Estates could not deduct Rs 15.21 lakh of subvention-scheme pre-EMI interest from a refund owed to homebuyers.
Key points
- The Punjab State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission on 17 November 2026 ruled on homebuyers' plea to enforce a 2022 refund order against ATS Estates.
- It accepted the homebuyers' claim that Rs 18,60,708 was still due and rejected a Rs 15,21,060 pre-EMI interest deduction.
- The builder must pay without further delay, the commission said; the order may be appealed.
The Punjab State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission on 17 November 2026 held that ATS Estates Pvt. Ltd. must pay two homebuyers the Rs 18,60,708 they said was still owed under a 2022 refund order. The commission rejected the builder's attempt to deduct Rs 15,21,060 that a bank had kept as pre-EMI interest under a subvention scheme.
What Happened
On 24 November 2022 the commission had ordered the builder to hand over a flat in its project near Derabassi within three months or, failing that, to refund Rs 69,81,995 with interest at 9% a year from each date of payment, plus Rs 80,000 as compensation. According to the order, the flat was not handed over, and the homebuyers filed an execution application in September 2023.
The builder made part-payments between 20 December 2023 and 2 May 2025 and argued it had overpaid by Rs 1,71,414. It said it had received Rs 40,62,734 from HDFC Bank, not Rs 55,83,750, because the bank had deducted Rs 15,21,060 as pre-EMI interest under the subvention scheme. A subvention scheme is an arrangement in which the builder pays the interest on the buyer's home loan for a set period.
Relying on Supreme Court and National Commission rulings, the commission held that the builder cannot reduce its refund liability by this deduction and must refund the entire amount received for the flat. It accepted the homebuyers' calculation, which it said the builder had not controverted with evidence, and directed payment without further delay. It left the builder free to take up the deduction with HDFC Bank. It found no intentional non-compliance and declined to punish the builder under the Consumer Protection Act. The order may be appealed.
What It Means
For homebuyers who bought under a subvention scheme and won a refund, the ruling supports the position that the builder must return the full amount paid for the flat, and cannot pass on interest settled with the lender. If a builder does not comply with a consumer commission's order, the homebuyer can file an execution application before the same commission. New complaints can be filed through e-Daakhil, and help is available on the National Consumer Helpline, 1915.
Source: Consumer commission order
Sources & Citations
- Consumer commission order — Consumer commission