Sued by Your Bank in the DRT? How Set-Off and Counter-Claim Under Section 19 of the RDB Act Let a Borrower Hit Back
Section 19 of the RDB Act lets a borrower sued in the DRT claim set-off or counter-claim damages against the bank, but only within 30 days and on affidavit. Here is the procedure and case law.
Key points
- Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993 lets a borrower sued by a bank in the DRT claim set-off or file a counter-claim in the same case.
- The written statement carrying either claim must be filed within 30 days of service of summons, extendable by 15 days only in exceptional cases, and must be on affidavit.
- The Supreme Court held in 2006 that a counter-claim is optional, so a borrower may instead sue the bank in a civil court, and that suit cannot be moved to the DRT against the borrower's wishes.
A bank that files an Original Application before a Debts Recovery Tribunal expects the borrower to defend, delay or settle. Few borrowers realise that Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993 (formerly the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act) also lets them go on the attack inside the same proceeding. Sub-sections (6) to (11) of Section 19 give a defendant two distinct weapons: a set-off of an ascertained sum the bank owes, and a counter-claim for any right or claim against the bank, including damages. Both are tried with the bank's own claim and decided by one final order.
This playbook walks through the statutory text, the 30-day clock that governs the written statement, the affidavit rule that sinks careless pleadings, and the Supreme Court's 18 April 2006 judgement in Indian Bank v. ABS Marine Products Pvt. Ltd., (2006) 5 SCC 72, which remains the leading word on what a DRT counter-claim can and cannot do. It is general legal information, not advice on any particular case; outcomes depend on the facts and the documents, and nothing here is a promise of result. For the wider recovery landscape, see our glossary entries on the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT) and the SARFAESI Act.
The Statutory Position
Section 19 of the 1993 Act is the procedural core of every bank recovery case before a DRT. The set-off and counter-claim provisions were not in the Act as originally enacted. As the Supreme Court recorded in paragraph 15 of ABS Marine, the absence of any provision enabling a defendant to claim set-off or make a counter-claim was among the grounds on which the Delhi High Court held the Act unconstitutional in Delhi High Court Bar Association v. Union of India, AIR 1995 Delhi 323. While the appeal was pending, Parliament substituted Section 19 in its entirety by Act 1 of 2000, and the amended Act was upheld in Union of India v. Delhi High Court Bar Association, 2002 (4) SCC 275.
The current text of Section 19, available on Indian Kanoon, contains the following provisions relevant to a borrower who wants to hit back:
| Sub-section | What it provides | Deadline or condition |
|---|---|---|
| 19(5)(i) | Written statement of defence, which may include a set-off under (6) or a counter-claim under (8) | Within 30 days of service of summons; extendable by up to 15 more days only in exceptional cases, with reasons recorded in writing |
| 19(5A) | Tribunal fixes a date for admission or denial of documents and decides whether any interim order under (4) continues | After the written statement is filed or the time for it expires |
| 19(5B) | If the defendant admits all or part of the debt, payment of the admitted amount is ordered | Within 30 days, failing which a recovery certificate under (22) may issue for that amount |
| 19(6) | Set-off of an ascertained sum legally recoverable from the applicant bank | At the first hearing; later only with leave of the Tribunal |
| 19(7) | Written statement has the effect of a plaint in a cross-suit | One final order on claim and set-off |
| 19(8) | Counter-claim for any right or claim against the applicant, damages or otherwise | Cause of action must arise before the defence is delivered or the time for it expires |
| 19(9) | Counter-claim has the effect of a cross-suit | One final order on claim and counter-claim |
| 19(10) | Bank may reply to the counter-claim | Within the prescribed period |
| 19(10A), (10B) | Pleadings, including set-off and counter-claim, must be on affidavit | Unverified facts are not treated as evidence |
| 19(11) | Bank may argue the counter-claim should be tried in an independent action | Tribunal decides that question along with the claim |
| 19(24) | Tribunal to endeavour to dispose of the application | Within 180 days |
Two points from this table shape every strategy. First, the 30-day window in Section 19(5)(i) is short, and the 15-day extension is the exception, not the rule. Second, under Section 19(10A) and (10B) a set-off or counter-claim that is not on affidavit, or is supported only by unverified assertions, does not count as evidence at all.
Set-off versus counter-claim at a glance
The two remedies overlap but are not the same, and a single written statement can contain both.
| Feature | Set-off, s.19(6) | Counter-claim, s.19(8) |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of claim | An ascertained sum of money | Any right or claim, including unliquidated damages |
| Legal status | Written statement acts as a plaint in a cross-suit, s.19(7) | Counter-claim acts as a cross-suit, s.19(9) |
| When to raise | At the first hearing; later only with leave | Cause of action must accrue before the defence is delivered or time to deliver it expires |
| Bank's response | Contested within the same proceeding | Bank may reply under s.19(10) and seek exclusion under s.19(11) |
| Outcome | One final order on claim and set-off | One final order on claim and counter-claim |
| Typical example | Excess sum debited that the account statement itself shows | Damages for loss allegedly caused by the bank's conduct |
Procedure Step by Step
The sequence below follows the order of the sub-sections in Section 19. Dates run from service of the summons, so the first task on receipt of any DRT notice is to record the exact date of service.
- Record the date of service (Day 0). Every deadline under Section 19(5)(i) runs from service of summons. Note the date on the envelope, the acknowledgement card and any email service.
- Obtain the full Original Application and annexures (Days 1 to 5). The bank's claim, account statements and sanction letters are the raw material for any set-off. A borrower cannot claim set-off of an "ascertained sum" under Section 19(6) without numbers to point to.
- Reconcile the account (Days 3 to 15). Compare every debit against the sanction terms. Mark entries that look like wrongful debits, excess interest or penal charges beyond what the agreement allows. Tools such as our penal charge check calculator can help frame the arithmetic, though only the documents prove it.
- Classify each grievance (Days 10 to 20). A precise, quantified overcharge is a candidate for set-off under Section 19(6). A claim for loss of business, reputation or other damages belongs in a counter-claim under Section 19(8).
- Check the cause-of-action date. Section 19(8) admits a counter-claim only where the cause of action arose before the defence is delivered or before the time for delivering it expires. Anything arising later must go elsewhere.
- Draft the written statement on affidavit (by Day 30). Sections 19(10A) and 19(10B) require the pleading, including any set-off or counter-claim, to be on affidavit, with supporting documents filed alongside under Section 19(5)(i).
- If genuinely unable to meet Day 30, apply for extension with reasons. The Presiding Officer may allow up to 15 more days, a total of 45 days at most, and only in exceptional cases with special circumstances recorded in writing.
- Attend the admission and denial hearing. Under Section 19(5A) the Tribunal fixes a date for admission or denial of documents and decides whether any interim order under Section 19(4) continues.
- Expect the bank's reply. Section 19(10) gives the bank a prescribed period to answer the counter-claim, and under Section 19(11) it may press for the counter-claim to be tried as an independent action.
- Final order. Under Sections 19(7) and 19(9), the Tribunal passes one final order covering the bank's claim and the set-off or counter-claim. Section 19(24) directs it to endeavour to dispose of the matter within 180 days.
The 30-day clock in numbers
| Milestone | Outer limit | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Written statement with set-off or counter-claim | 30 days from service of summons | s.19(5)(i) |
| Maximum extension | 15 days (45 days in total) | s.19(5)(i) |
| Payment of any admitted amount | 30 days from the order | s.19(5B) |
| Target disposal of the bank's application | 180 days | s.19(24) |
A missed deadline is the single most avoidable way to lose a counter-claim. The 15-day extension is discretionary, so a borrower should plan to file within the first 30 days and treat the extension as insurance, not a plan.
Borrower Defences Available
Section 19 does not list grounds of defence; it provides the procedure through which any lawful ground can be raised. The illustrations below are examples only. Whether any of them succeeds depends entirely on the loan documents, the account history and the evidence filed on affidavit.
| Possible grievance | Likely route | What must be shown |
|---|---|---|
| Wrongful debits to the loan account | Set-off, s.19(6), if the amount is ascertained | The specific entries and the contractual term they breach |
| Excess penal charges or interest beyond the agreement | Set-off, s.19(6), or counter-claim, s.19(8) | The sanction terms and the computation of the excess |
| Damages from wrongful SARFAESI action | Counter-claim, s.19(8) | The action complained of, the loss and its link to the bank's conduct |
| Loss caused by non-release of a sanctioned facility | Counter-claim, s.19(8), or a separate civil suit | The sanction, the breach and the quantified loss |
Admit what is admitted, contest the rest
Section 19(5B) works in both directions. If the written statement admits part of the debt, the Tribunal orders that admitted amount paid within 30 days, and a recovery certificate under Section 19(22) may issue for it if payment is not made. A borrower who intends to argue that only part of a claim is payable should know that the admitted portion becomes enforceable quickly. Before deciding what to concede, it is worth running the numbers on the alternatives; our settlement cost calculator models what a negotiated one-time settlement might cost against the full claim, and the loan foreclosure calculator shows the cost of closing an account outright.
Set-off must be ascertained
The word "ascertained" in Section 19(6) matters. A set-off is for a definite sum legally recoverable from the bank, raised at the first hearing and supported by particulars and documents. A claim that requires the Tribunal first to decide liability and then to assess loss, as the Supreme Court described the borrower's Rs 25,38,58,000 damages claim in ABS Marine, is a counter-claim, not a set-off.
Counter-claims can include damages
Section 19(8) expressly allows a counter-claim "whether such counter-claim is in the nature of a claim for damages or not", in the words quoted by the Supreme Court in paragraph 11 of ABS Marine. That allows a borrower to plead loss caused by the bank's conduct, provided the cause of action arose within the window in Section 19(8) and the facts are verified on affidavit under Section 19(10A).
The option to sue separately
Paragraph 16 of ABS Marine makes clear that a counter-claim is "not the only remedy, but an option". A borrower may instead file a separate suit before a civil court or other appropriate forum. This choice has tactical consequences discussed in the next section.
Recent Tribunal/HC Position
The leading authority on DRT counter-claims is the Supreme Court's judgement in Indian Bank v. ABS Marine Products Pvt. Ltd., decided on 18 April 2006 by Dr AR Lakshmanan and RV Raveendran JJ in Civil Appeals 10074-10075 of 2003, reported at (2006) 5 SCC 72. The Court dismissed the bank's appeals against a 10 May 2002 judgement of a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court.
The facts
According to the judgement, Indian Bank sanctioned ad hoc packing credit limits of Rs 20 lakh on 12 July 1991 and Rs 5 lakh on 6 December 1991. On 21 August 1995 it filed O.A. No. 170/1995 before the DRT under Section 19 to recover Rs 30,67,820.04 with interest from the company and its four guarantor directors. Separately, on 19 December 1991 the bank had sanctioned a Medium Term Loan of Rs 90 lakh and other facilities that were never released. In January 1995 the company sued the bank in the Calcutta High Court (C.S. No. 7/1995) for Rs 25,38,58,000 in damages for non-disbursal. The bank sought to transfer the borrower's suit to the DRT to be tried as a counter-claim.
What the Supreme Court held
| Issue | Holding in ABS Marine (2006) |
|---|---|
| Nature of s.19(6) to (11) | "Merely enabling provisions"; they permit a cross-action within a pending bank application (para 15) |
| Civil court jurisdiction over borrower suits | Not barred; Sections 17 and 18 bar civil courts only for bank applications to recover debts (para 14) |
| Is a counter-claim compulsory? | No; it is an option, and a borrower may file a separate suit (para 16) |
| Can a borrower's independent suit be transferred to the DRT against the borrower's wishes? | No (para 16) |
| What if the DRT excludes a counter-claim? | The borrower must go to the civil court, because the Tribunal cannot try an independent claim against a bank (para 16) |
| When can an earlier borrower suit be treated as a counter-claim? | Only if the two matters are inextricably connected and both parties agree (para 23) |
On the facts, the Court found "absolutely no connection" between the bank's claim for an ascertained sum and the borrower's damages claim for non-release of a separate loan. It also clarified the earlier ruling in United Bank of India v. Abhijit Tea Co. Pvt. Ltd., 2000 (7) SCC 357, holding that its observations on treating a borrower's suit as a counter-claim apply only where both conditions in paragraph 23 are met.
What it means for borrowers today
Three practical lessons follow. First, a counter-claim filed within the Section 19(5)(i) window keeps everything in one forum, with one final order under Section 19(9). Second, a borrower who has already filed a civil suit before the bank went to the DRT cannot be forced to move that suit to the Tribunal. Third, because the bank can ask for a counter-claim to be tried independently under Section 19(11), a borrower should be ready for the possibility that a counter-claim is excluded and has to be pursued in a civil court.
The Oquilia Research Desk has not identified, for this playbook, a later Supreme Court ruling that departs from ABS Marine on these points; readers with a live case should check for subsequent High Court and DRAT decisions in their own jurisdiction.
FAQ
What is the deadline to file a counter-claim in the DRT?
The counter-claim is part of the written statement under Section 19(5)(i), which must be filed within 30 days of service of summons. The Presiding Officer may extend this by up to 15 more days only in exceptional cases with reasons recorded in writing.
What is the difference between set-off and counter-claim under Section 19?
A set-off under Section 19(6) is for an ascertained sum legally recoverable from the bank and is raised at the first hearing. A counter-claim under Section 19(8) can be for any right or claim, including damages, if the cause of action arose before the defence is delivered or the time for it expires.
Does the counter-claim need to be on affidavit?
Yes. Sections 19(10A) and 19(10B) require pleadings, including set-off and counter-claim, to be on affidavit, and facts that are not verified are not treated as evidence.
Can the bank stop my counter-claim being heard in the DRT?
Under Section 19(11), the bank may argue that the counter-claim should be tried as an independent action, and the Tribunal decides that question. The Supreme Court noted in paragraph 16 of ABS Marine (2006) that an excluded counter-claim must then be pursued in a civil court.
Can the bank move my existing civil suit to the DRT?
According to Indian Bank v. ABS Marine Products, (2006) 5 SCC 72, an independent suit by a borrower cannot be transferred to the Tribunal against the borrower's wishes. Treating it as a counter-claim requires the matters to be inextricably connected and both parties to agree.
What happens if I admit part of the bank's claim?
Under Section 19(5B), the Tribunal orders payment of the admitted amount within 30 days. If it is not paid, a recovery certificate under Section 19(22) may issue for that amount.
How long does a DRT case take?
Section 19(24) directs the Tribunal to endeavour to dispose of the application within 180 days. This is a target, not a guarantee.
Sources & Citations
- Section 19, Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993 — Indian Kanoon
- Indian Bank vs Abs Marine Products Pvt. Ltd on 18 April, 2006 — Indian Kanoon (Supreme Court of India)