Calcutta High Court sets aside PNB fraud tag on borrower's loan account
The Calcutta High Court set aside Punjab National Bank's fraud classification of a borrower's account, holding the bank had to supply the full forensic audit report it relied on.
Key points
- The Calcutta High Court on 20 November 2026 set aside Punjab National Bank's classification of a company's loan account as fraud.
- The court held the bank must furnish the forensic audit report it relied on, withholding only parts it justifies with recorded reasons.
- The bank must take the borrowers' written reply and pass a fresh reasoned order; its recovery case before the DRT can continue.

Photo: Biswarup Ganguly / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0 (cropped). File photo.
The Calcutta High Court on 20 November 2026 set aside Punjab National Bank's decision to classify the loan account of a cold storage and manure company as a "fraud account", holding that the bank had not supplied the full forensic audit report it relied on. The court revived the bank's show-cause notice of 21 December 2023 and told the bank to decide afresh.
What Happened
Siddhi Vinayak Himghar (P) Ltd. and its directors challenged the bank's show-cause notice and its letter of 21 March 2024, which told them their account had been classified as fraud. According to the judgment, the bank relied on a forensic audit report but admitted it had furnished only extracts, saying the rest contained statements about bank officials and third parties.
The court held, following the Supreme Court's ruling in State Bank of India v. Amit Iron Private Limited, that supplying the forensic audit report to the borrower is mandatory. A bank may withhold only those portions that affect the privacy or rights of third parties, and it must record reasons identifying each portion it withholds. The court said the bank's internal circular could not override the law declared by the Supreme Court.
The court also held that a borrower has no right to a personal or oral hearing; a written representation after disclosure of the material meets the requirement of natural justice. It ordered the bank to furnish the report, take the borrowers' representation and pass a fresh, reasoned order under the applicable RBI Directions.
The court expressly said it expressed no opinion on the bank's allegations of diversion or misuse of funds, which remain open for the bank to decide, and that its order does not stop the bank's recovery case before the Debts Recovery Tribunal.
What It Means
A fraud classification is a serious step for a borrower. Under this ruling, a bank that relies on a forensic audit must hand the report to the borrower before deciding, and explain any part it holds back. Borrowers facing such a notice can ask for the full report. The judgment is the High Court's holding and may be appealed. Complaints about a bank's service can be filed with the RBI at https://cms.rbi.org.in.
Source: High Court judgment
Sources & Citations
- High Court judgment — Calcutta High Court