Mutual Fund Basics
Regular vs Direct Mutual Fund: How the Cost Difference Adds Up
Every mutual fund scheme in India has a regular plan and a direct plan. Same fund, same manager, same portfolio, but two expense ratios and two NAVs. The difference is the distribution commission, and it compounds for as long as the units are held.
1 Jan 2013
Direct plan required in every scheme
Two NAVs
One portfolio, two plans
₹10.79L
Example gap: ₹10,000 a month, 20 years, 11% vs 10%
Taxable
A switch is a sale and a fresh purchase
How Regular and Direct Plans Work
SEBI's circular of 13 September 2012 required every mutual fund scheme to offer a separate plan for investments not routed through a distributor, from 1 January 2013. The direct plan carries a lower expense ratio because it excludes distribution expenses and commission, and it has its own NAV. Before then, units were sold through distributors (banks, brokers and individual agents) whose commission was paid out of the scheme's expenses.
In a regular plan, the fund house still pays the distributor a trail commission for as long as the investor holds the units, and that cost is part of the plan's total expense ratio (TER). The TER is charged daily against the plan's assets, so the investor pays it through slightly lower NAV growth rather than as a separate bill.
The word "direct" refers to the plan, not to the website or app used to buy it. A direct plan can be bought from the fund house, through the online platform the two registrars run jointly, or through online investment platforms that offer direct plans, as long as the plan chosen is the one whose name ends in "Direct". Units bought through a distributor are normally in the regular plan.
Regular Plan: How It Works
- 1Investor buys through a distributor: a bank, broker or agent with an AMFI registration number (ARN)
- 2The fund house pays the distributor a commission, usually as a yearly trail on the holding
- 3The commission is part of the regular plan's total expense ratio
- 4The TER is deducted daily, so the regular plan's NAV grows a little less than the direct plan's
- 5The half-yearly consolidated account statement shows the commission paid, in rupees, per scheme
Direct Plan: How It Works
- 1Investor buys from the fund house or through a platform that offers direct plans
- 2No distributor commission is paid by the fund house
- 3The direct plan's TER excludes distribution commission, so it is lower
- 4Same fund manager and same portfolio as the regular plan
- 5Any adviser's fee or platform fee is paid by the investor separately
Where the Cost Difference Shows
The TER gap between the two plans differs from scheme to scheme and can change during the year within SEBI's limits. These are the documents that show it for a particular holding.
| Document | What It Shows | What It Tells You |
|---|---|---|
| Fund house website and factsheet | TER of each plan of each scheme | The gap between the two TERs is the yearly cost difference |
| Half-yearly consolidated account statement | Gross commission paid to the distributor, in rupees, per scheme | The commission on that investor's own holding for the half-year |
| Account statement and order confirmation | Plan name ending in "Regular" or "Direct" | Which plan the units are actually in |
| Daily NAV history | Two NAVs for one scheme | The direct plan's NAV moves ahead of the regular plan's over time |
The commission figure on the consolidated account statement is gross: it is what the fund house paid, before the distributor's own costs and taxes.
Example: How a One-Point Gap Compounds
Rs 10,000 a month, invested at the start of each month. The direct plan is shown at an example net return of 11% a year and the regular plan at 10% a year, a gap of one percentage point chosen to make the arithmetic easy to follow. These are example rates, not a forecast: the real gap for a scheme is the difference between its two TERs, and no fund's return is known in advance. Figures use Oquilia's SIP calculator method (monthly compounding).
| Years | Invested | Direct Plan (example 11%) | Regular Plan (example 10%) | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | ₹6,00,000 | ₹8,02,470 | ₹7,80,824 | ₹21,646 |
| 10 years | ₹12,00,000 | ₹21,89,873 | ₹20,65,520 | ₹1,24,353 |
| 15 years | ₹18,00,000 | ₹45,88,576 | ₹41,79,243 | ₹4,09,333 |
| 20 years | ₹24,00,000 | ₹87,35,731 | ₹76,56,969 | ₹10,78,762 |
| 25 years | ₹30,00,000 | ₹1,59,05,812 | ₹1,33,78,903 | ₹25,26,909 |
| 30 years | ₹36,00,000 | ₹2,83,02,278 | ₹2,27,93,253 | ₹55,09,025 |
At these example rates the gap after 20 years is Rs 10,78,762, about 14% more than the regular plan's Rs 76,56,969. After 30 years it is Rs 55,09,025, about 24% more. The cost is a percentage of the whole balance every year, so the rupee gap grows fastest in the later years, when the balance is largest. A smaller TER gap gives a smaller difference, and a larger gap a larger one.
How a Switch from Regular to Direct Works
For income tax, a switch from the regular plan to the direct plan of the same scheme is a redemption of the regular-plan units followed by a fresh purchase of direct-plan units. Any gain on the units switched is taxed in that tax year, and the scheme's exit load can apply. There are two separate steps: the units already held, and any SIP still running.
Step 1: Units Already Held
- 1
Find the regular-plan holdings on the consolidated account statement
The plan name says Regular or Direct
- 2
Check the purchase dates against the exit-load period in the scheme information document
Some schemes exempt a switch within the same scheme; many do not
- 3
Check any ELSS units for the three-year lock-in
Locked-in units cannot be switched
- 4
Place a switch to the direct plan of the same scheme
Through the fund house, the registrars' joint platform, or a platform that accepts switches
- 5
The regular units are redeemed and direct units bought at the applicable NAVs
Partial or full switches are possible
Step 2: SIPs Still Running
- 1
A SIP is registered for one plan of a scheme
Switching units does not move the SIP
- 2
Cancel the regular-plan SIP with the fund house or the platform it was set up on
Otherwise it keeps buying regular-plan units
- 3
Register a new SIP in the direct plan
Check that the plan name ends in Direct before confirming
- 4
Platforms that show both plans of a scheme list them separately
Some platforms charge a subscription or transaction fee
The Tax on a Switch
For equity-oriented funds, units held more than 12 months are taxed at 12.5% on the tax year's total long-term equity gains above Rs 1,25,000 (Income-tax Act, 2025, section 198), and units held 12 months or less at 20% (section 196), plus cess. Because the Rs 1,25,000 exemption applies each tax year, a switch spread over more than one tax year can use it more than once. Example: long-term gains of Rs 5,00,000 switched in one year leave Rs 3,75,000 taxable, tax Rs 46,875 (Rs 48,750 with cess). The same gains split equally over two tax years leave Rs 1,25,000 taxable each year, Rs 31,250 in all (Rs 32,500 with cess), assuming no other equity gains. Debt fund units bought on or after 1 April 2023 are taxed at slab rates whatever the holding period.
What the Regular Plan's Extra Cost Pays For
The commission in a regular plan pays the distributor for selling and servicing the investment. Whether that service is worth the cost depends on what is actually provided. A SEBI-registered investment adviser works on a different model: the client pays the adviser a fee, and the adviser does not take commission from the fund house.
What a Distributor's Service Can Include
- Help choosing schemes and opening the investment, including KYC paperwork
- Setting up and changing SIPs, switches and redemptions
- Periodic reviews of the holdings against the investor's goals
- Help with nominations, transmission and account changes
- A person to call during market falls
Questions to Ask Before Buying a Regular Plan
- Which plan of the scheme is this order for, regular or direct?
- What is the TER of each plan of this scheme today?
- Is the seller an AMFI-registered distributor or a SEBI-registered investment adviser?
- Does the commission differ between the schemes being offered?
- What commission did the fund house pay on these holdings last half-year? (It is on the consolidated account statement.)
Where Direct Plans Can Be Bought
The fund house
No platform feeUsed for: Investing with one or a few fund housesEvery fund house accepts direct-plan purchases, SIPs, switches and redemptions on its own website, app or at its offices. Each fund house account covers only that fund house's schemes.
The registrars' joint platform
No platform feeUsed for: Seeing and switching holdings across fund housesThe two registrars that keep mutual fund records run a joint online platform that shows holdings across fund houses and accepts transactions, including switches from regular to direct plans of the same scheme.
Online investment platforms
Fees varyUsed for: One account across fund housesMany online platforms offer direct plans across fund houses. Some charge a subscription or transaction fee, and some list both plans of a scheme, so the plan name needs checking before an order is confirmed.
A SEBI-registered investment adviser
Adviser's feeUsed for: Advice paid for by fee rather than commissionAn investment adviser charges the client a fee for advice and does not take commission from fund houses. The fee is paid separately, not through the scheme's expense ratio.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between regular and direct mutual funds?
Regular and direct plans are two plans of the same mutual fund scheme. They hold one portfolio, run by the same fund manager. In a regular plan, the fund house pays a commission to the distributor through whom the units were bought, and that cost sits inside the plan's total expense ratio (TER). A direct plan has no distributor commission, so its TER is lower and its NAV is published separately. SEBI's circular of 13 September 2012 required every scheme to offer a separate direct plan from 1 January 2013.
How much does the cost difference add up to?
It depends on the gap between the two plans' TERs, which differs by scheme and changes over time. As an example only: Rs 10,000 a month for 20 years at an example net return of 11% a year (direct) against 10% a year (regular) gives Rs 87,35,731 against Rs 76,56,969, a difference of Rs 10,78,762 on Rs 24,00,000 invested. These are example rates, not a forecast of any fund's return.
Where can I see the TER and the commission I am paying?
Fund houses publish the TER of each plan of each scheme, and the scheme factsheet shows both. Under SEBI's 2016 rules on the consolidated account statement, the half-yearly statement shows, for each scheme held, the gross commission in rupees that the fund house paid to the distributor on that investor's holding.
How do I switch from a regular plan to a direct plan?
Place a switch request from the regular plan to the direct plan of the same scheme, through the fund house's website or office, the online platform the two registrars run jointly, or any platform that accepts switches. The regular-plan units are redeemed and direct-plan units are bought at the applicable NAVs. The scheme's exit load can apply to units still within the exit-load period; the scheme information document says whether a switch within the scheme is exempt. ELSS units cannot be switched until their three-year lock-in ends.
Is switching from regular to direct taxable?
Yes. For income tax the switch is a redemption of the regular-plan units followed by a fresh purchase, so any gain is taxed in that tax year. For an equity-oriented fund, units held more than 12 months are taxed at 12.5% on the year's total long-term equity gains above Rs 1,25,000 (Income-tax Act, 2025, section 198), and units held 12 months or less at 20% (section 196). These rates apply to transfers from 23 July 2024. Gains on debt fund units bought on or after 1 April 2023 are taxed at slab rates whatever the holding period. Cess, and surcharge where it applies, is added.
Does the same fund manager manage both direct and regular plans?
Yes. Both plans of a scheme share one portfolio, mandate and benchmark. The only difference is the expense ratio, which is charged daily against each plan's assets. Because the regular plan's NAV grows a little less every day, the gap between the two NAVs widens the longer the scheme runs.
Who gets paid in each plan?
In a regular plan, the fund house pays commission to the mutual fund distributor, who is registered with AMFI and holds an ARN. A SEBI-registered investment adviser is paid a fee by the client and does not take commission from the fund house. A direct-plan investor pays no distributor commission, but may pay an adviser's fee or a platform fee separately.
Does a running SIP move to the direct plan when units are switched?
No. A SIP is registered for one plan of a scheme. Switching the units already held leaves a regular-plan SIP buying regular-plan units until it is cancelled, and a SIP in the direct plan is set up separately.
Calculators
Work out the gap for your own figures
The SIP calculator projects a monthly investment at any return rate entered, so the two plans can be compared at two rates one TER gap apart. The capital gains calculator works out the tax on units sold or switched, by holding period.