Investment Comparison
ULIP vs Mutual Fund: Charges, Lock-In and Tax Compared
A unit linked insurance plan (ULIP) is a life insurance policy, regulated by IRDAI, that puts part of each premium into market-linked funds. A mutual fund is an investment scheme regulated by SEBI, with no life cover. This guide sets out how their charges, lock-in and tax treatment differ for tax year 2026-27. It does not recommend either.
5 years
ULIP lock-in (IRDAI, 12 June 2024)
Rs 2,50,000
Yearly ULIP premium limit for tax-free maturity
12.5%
Equity fund gains above Rs 1,25,000 (s.198)
Nil
GST on individual life premiums
What Is a ULIP and How Does It Work?
A ULIP is a life insurance policy regulated by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI). Part of each premium buys units in funds the policyholder chooses, such as equity, debt or balanced funds, and charges for the life cover, administration and fund management are deducted under the policy's terms. The fund value moves with the market. On maturity the policy pays the fund value; on death it pays the death benefit the policy sets out.
The current rules are in the IRDAI (Insurance Products) Regulations, 2024 and IRDAI's Master Circular on Life Insurance Products of 12 June 2024. They set a five-year lock-in, require a benefit illustration at the point of sale showing the policy's values at assumed gross returns of 4% and 8% a year, cap discontinuance charges during the lock-in, and require the fund of a discontinued policy to earn at least 4% a year until it is paid out.
A mutual fund deducts its expense ratio from the scheme's assets, and a direct plan has a lower expense ratio than the regular plan of the same scheme. It provides no life cover, so a like-for-like comparison adds the cost of a separate term policy. What decides the result is how much of each rupee reaches the fund under each product, what the fund keeps each year, and how the proceeds are taxed.
How a ULIP Premium Is Applied
Premium Paid
For example, Rs 1 lakh a year
Allocation Charge Deducted
At the rate the policy sets, if any
Units Allocated to Funds
The rest buys units in the chosen funds
Charges Taken From the Fund
Mortality, administration and fund management
ULIP vs Mutual Fund: The Charges Compared
Charges decide how much of each premium is invested and how much the fund keeps each year, and their effect compounds. In an assumed example of a lump sum held for 20 years, a net return of 11% a year instead of 12% leaves a final value about 16% lower.
| Charge | ULIP | Mutual Fund |
|---|---|---|
| Premium allocation charge | Deducted from each premium before it is invested; the rate is set in the policy | None |
| Mortality charge | Pays for the life cover; depends on age and the sum at risk | None (no life cover) |
| Policy administration charge | As set in the policy | None |
| Fund management charge | A percentage of the fund value, as set in the policy | Expense ratio on the scheme's assets; lower in a direct plan than in a regular plan |
| Leaving early | Discontinuance charge in the five-year lock-in, capped by IRDAI regulations | Exit load, if the scheme document sets one |
| Changing funds | Switch within the policy; some switches may be free, others charged | Redemption and a new purchase; exit load and capital gains tax may apply |
| Where the figures are | Benefit illustration and policy document | Scheme information document and factsheet |
Sources: IRDAI Master Circular on Life Insurance Products, 12 June 2024, and the IRDAI (Insurance Products) Regulations, 2024, for ULIPs; each scheme's information document for mutual fund expenses and exit loads. Mortality charges rise with age.
A Worked Example on Assumed Figures
These are the default inputs of Oquilia's ULIP vs mutual fund calculator, not the charges of any product: Rs 1 lakh a year for 15 years and a gross return of 12% a year on both; for the ULIP, an 8% allocation charge (which the calculator applies at three times that rate in years 1 to 3, at that rate in years 4 to 10 and at 40% of it after that), a Rs 3,000 yearly mortality charge and a 1.35% fund management charge; for the mutual fund, a 0.5% expense ratio. The 12% return is an input for the arithmetic, not an expected return.
Rs 30.96 lakh
ULIP fund value after 15 years
Charges over the term: Rs 4.46 lakh. Includes life cover. Outside tax at maturity only if the sum assured is at least ten times the premium and all ULIPs issued from 1 February 2021 stay within Rs 2,50,000 a year.
Rs 39.72 lakh
Mutual fund value after 15 years, before tax
Expenses over the term: Rs 1.21 lakh. No life cover. Rs 15 lakh invested; gain Rs 24.72 lakh.
Rs 36.67 lakh
Mutual fund value after tax on the gain
Tax of Rs 3.05 lakh: 12.5% on the gain above Rs 1,25,000 plus 4% cess, assuming every unit is held for more than 12 months, redeemed in one tax year, before any surcharge.
On these inputs the ULIP fund value stands at Rs 5.36 lakh after five years against Rs 7.00 lakh for the mutual fund, and does not catch up within 15 or 30 years. With lower ULIP charges, or a higher expense ratio such as a regular plan's, the gap narrows. A real policy's charges are in its benefit illustration, and returns are not known in advance. The mutual fund figures include no life cover.
How the Tax Treatment Differs for Tax Year 2026-27
Premiums. Under the old regime, a ULIP premium counts towards the Rs 1,50,000 deduction in section 123 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (the old 80C) under Schedule XV, paragraph 1(a), up to 10% of the actual capital sum assured for a policy issued on or after 1 April 2012 (15% for some policies covering a person with a disability or a specified illness). ELSS investments count under paragraph 1(m). The new regime in section 202 allows neither.
ULIP maturity. Schedule II, Sl. No. 2 (the old 10(10D)) excludes a ULIP's maturity proceeds from income only if, for a ULIP issued on or after 1 February 2021, the premium is within 10% of the sum assured (15% for a special policy) and the aggregate premium for all such ULIPs is not more than Rs 2,50,000 in any tax year of their term. A ULIP with a larger aggregate premium does not get the exclusion: it is a capital asset (section 2(22)(c)), and where its fund keeps at least 65% in listed Indian shares throughout the term of the policy, it counts as an equity-oriented fund for section 198 (section 198(8)), which taxes long-term gains at 12.5% above Rs 1,25,000 where its other conditions are met. The conditions do not apply to a sum received on death, though sums under a Keyman insurance policy are not covered by the exclusion.
Mutual funds. Long-term gains on equity-oriented fund units (held over 12 months) are taxed at 12.5% on the year's total above Rs 1,25,000 (section 198(2)), and short-term gains at 20% (section 196(1)); surcharge on these gains is capped at 15%, and 4% cess applies. Gains on a specified mutual fund, one with more than 65% in debt and money-market instruments, bought on or after 1 April 2023 are taxed at slab rates (section 76). Premiums for individual life policies, including ULIPs, carry no GST from 22 September 2025.
Points that work in the ULIP's favour
- Low charges in the policy's benefit illustration
- Maturity proceeds that meet the Schedule II conditions
- A long holding period, over which early charges are spread
- A need for life cover, which a mutual fund does not provide
Points that work in the mutual fund's favour
- A low expense ratio, as in a direct plan
- No lock-in, except in ELSS schemes
- ULIP premiums above Rs 2,50,000 a year in all, which lose the maturity exclusion
- Life cover already held through a separate term policy
- Money that may be needed within five years, when ULIP discontinuance charges apply
How to Read a ULIP Benefit Illustration
IRDAI's Master Circular on Life Insurance Products of 12 June 2024 requires a benefit illustration at the point of sale, signed by the policyholder and the agent. It shows the policy's values at assumed gross returns of 4% and 8% a year; these are illustrations, not forecasts. The points to read:
Net yield at the 8% gross return
The illustration shows the net yield at 8% after all charges, taxes and commission, and the reduction in yield the charges cause. The reduction in yield is a yearly percentage, like a mutual fund's expense ratio, so the two can be compared directly.
The charges, year by year
The illustration sets out the premium allocation, mortality, administration and fund management charges deducted each year. Charges taken in the early years reduce the amount that compounds for the rest of the term.
The sum assured against the premium
For the maturity proceeds to be outside tax, the premium must be within 10% of the sum assured (15% for a special policy), so the sum assured must be at least ten times the annual premium, and all ULIPs issued from 1 February 2021 together must stay within Rs 2,50,000 a year.
The funds and the switches
The policy document lists the funds on offer, with the asset allocation range of each fund stated separately for equity, debt and money market, as IRDAI requires, and the number of switches that are free.
Free-look period: Under the same circular, a policyholder has 30 days from receiving the policy document to review its terms and cancel the policy if not satisfied, in line with the IRDAI (Protection of Policyholders' Interests, Operations and Allied Matters of Insurers) Regulations, 2024.
Switching Funds: ULIP vs Mutual Fund
A ULIP lets the policyholder move money between the policy's own funds, for example from an equity fund to a debt fund. Nothing is paid out of the policy; the tax question arises when money is paid out, on maturity, surrender or partial withdrawal, under the Schedule II conditions. A policy may allow some switches free each year and charge for others.
A mutual fund investor who moves from an equity scheme to a debt scheme redeems units and buys new ones. The redemption is a transfer, so capital gains on it are taxed in that year: 12.5% on long-term equity gains above Rs 1,25,000 and 20% on short-term equity gains. An exit load also applies if the scheme sets one.
The difference matters to someone who changes the mix of equity and debt over time, for example when moving towards debt nearer a goal. A holder who never switches is not affected by it.
ULIP Fund Switch
- 1Switch request made to the insurer
- 2Units moved between the policy's funds
- 3Nothing paid out of the policy
- 4Switching charge, once any free switches are used
- 5New mix shown in the policy statement
Mutual Fund Switch
- 1Redemption of the units held
- 2Long-term equity gains above Rs 1,25,000 taxed at 12.5%
- 3Short-term equity gains (held 12 months or less) taxed at 20%
- 4Exit load, if the scheme sets one
- 5Proceeds invested in the new scheme
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a ULIP better than a mutual fund?
Neither is better in every case; they are different products. A ULIP is a life insurance policy, regulated by IRDAI, that combines life cover with market-linked funds. A mutual fund is an investment scheme regulated by SEBI, with no life cover. A ULIP deducts the allocation, mortality, administration and fund management charges its benefit illustration sets out; a mutual fund deducts its expense ratio. The outcome depends on those charges, the return earned, how long the money stays invested, and whether the ULIP's maturity proceeds meet the tax conditions in Schedule II, Sl. No. 2 of the Income-tax Act, 2025. The ULIP vs mutual fund calculator compares the two on the charges you enter.
What are ULIP charges?
A ULIP can carry a premium allocation charge deducted from each premium before it is invested, a mortality charge for the life cover (which depends on age and the sum at risk), a policy administration charge, a fund management charge on the fund value, and switching, partial withdrawal or discontinuance charges. The benefit illustration and the policy document list the charges for the product. IRDAI's Master Circular on Life Insurance Products of 12 June 2024 requires the benefit illustration to include all charges, taxes and commission, and to state the reduction in yield they cause.
Is ULIP maturity tax-free?
Only if conditions are met. For tax year 2026-27, Schedule II, Sl. No. 2 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (the exemption the 1961 Act numbered 10(10D)) excludes a ULIP's maturity proceeds from income only if, for a ULIP issued on or after 1 February 2021, the premium is within 10% of the sum assured (15% for a special policy) and the aggregate premium for all such ULIPs is not more than Rs 2,50,000 in any tax year of their term. A ULIP that fails these conditions is a capital asset (section 2(22)(c)), and the gain on it is taxed as a capital gain. The conditions do not apply to a sum received on death, though sums under a Keyman insurance policy are not covered by the exclusion.
What is the ULIP lock-in period?
Five years. IRDAI's Master Circular on Life Insurance Products of 12 June 2024 sets a five-year lock-in for linked insurance products: in that period the policy proceeds are not paid to the policyholder except on death or another covered event, and partial withdrawals are allowed only after it ends. If premiums stop during the lock-in, the fund, less a capped discontinuance charge, moves to a discontinued policy fund that earns at least 4% a year and is paid out when the lock-in ends, unless the policy is revived. Open-ended mutual fund schemes have no lock-in, except tax-saving ELSS schemes.
Does switching funds in a ULIP create a tax bill?
A switch moves money between the policy's own funds; nothing is paid out of the policy. The tax question arises when money is paid out, on maturity, surrender or partial withdrawal, under the Schedule II conditions. A policy may allow some switches free each year and charge for others, as its terms state. In a mutual fund, moving from one scheme to another is a redemption followed by a new purchase; the redemption is a transfer, and capital gains on it are taxed in that year.
How do I check the net yield of a ULIP?
Read the benefit illustration, which IRDAI's Master Circular on Life Insurance Products of 12 June 2024 requires at the point of sale, signed by the policyholder and the agent. It shows the policy's values at assumed gross returns of 4% and 8% a year, which are illustrations, not forecasts. At 8% it shows the net yield after all charges, taxes and commission, and the reduction in yield the charges cause. The reduction in yield is a yearly percentage, like a mutual fund's expense ratio, so the two can be set side by side.
Should I surrender my ULIP after 5 years?
That depends on the policy and on what it is held for, and Oquilia does not advise on it. The points that can be compared are the surrender value against the fund value, the charges still to come, the life cover that would end and what replacing it would cost, and whether the maturity proceeds meet the Schedule II conditions. After the five-year lock-in, a surrender pays the fund value less any charge the policy terms set. The calculator can model the remaining years with the policy's own charges.
Do ULIP premiums count for the section 80C deduction?
Under the old regime, yes, within limits. A ULIP premium counts towards the Rs 1,50,000 deduction in section 123 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (the deduction the 1961 Act numbered 80C) under Schedule XV, paragraph 1(a), up to 10% of the actual capital sum assured for a policy issued on or after 1 April 2012 (15% for some policies covering a person with a disability or a specified illness). ELSS investments count under paragraph 1(m). The new regime under section 202 allows neither.
Is GST charged on ULIP premiums?
No. From 22 September 2025, premiums for individual life insurance policies, including ULIPs, carry no GST (Notification 16/2025-Central Tax (Rate)). Group policies remain taxable at 18%.
Calculator
ULIP and mutual fund, worked out side by side
Enter the premium, the charges and an assumed return; the calculator shows both values at the end of the term and the charges under each, before tax, and explains its method.
Open the ULIP vs mutual fund calculator