OquiliaOquilia

Index Funds and ETFs

Index Funds in India: Nifty 50, Next 50, Sensex and How to Compare Them

An index fund buys the shares of an index in the index's proportions, so its return follows the index less its costs. SEBI requires an index fund or ETF to keep at least 95% of its assets in the index's securities. This guide explains what the main Indian indices hold, how to compare two funds tracking the same index, how ETFs differ and how gains are taxed. It does not rank or pick funds.

95%
Minimum in the index
SEBI circular of 26 Feb 2026
Daily
Tracking error
Disclosed by every index fund
12.5%
Equity LTCG
Above Rs 1.25 lakh a year (s.198)
50 stocks
Nifty 50
Free-float weighted

Index Funds and Active Funds: What the Comparison Measures

S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes the SPIVA (S&P Indices versus Active) India scorecard, which reports the share of active funds in each category that did worse than their benchmark over one, three, five and ten years. Its findings differ by category and change from report to report, so the latest scorecard is the one to read. Points that hold whatever the figures:

  • An index fund does not try to beat its index; its return is the index return less costs and tracking difference.
  • An active fund's return depends on the manager's choices and can be well above or well below the benchmark.
  • Scorecards compare with the total return version of the index, which includes dividends.
  • Funds that were merged or closed drop out of ordinary return tables; SPIVA reports them separately, as survivorship.

The arithmetic of cost: Suppose a market earns 12% a year before costs. A fund costing 0.1% a year nets 11.9%; one costing 1.5% nets 10.5%. On Rs 50,000 a month for 20 years, that is Rs 4,92,85,490 against Rs 4,08,79,840: Rs 84,05,650, or about 17%, less. Over 10 years the gap is Rs 9,15,059. The rates are examples, not forecasts.

What to compare between index funds on the same index

ItemWhere to find it
Total expense ratioFactsheet; compare direct with direct
Tracking errorFund house website, published daily
Tracking differenceFund house website, published monthly
Assets under managementFactsheet
Exit loadFactsheet and scheme information document
For an ETF: trading volume and bid-ask spreadStock exchange quote

Disclosure rules from SEBI's circular on development of passive funds of 23 May 2022.

Tracking Error and Tracking Difference

Tracking error measures how consistently an index fund follows its benchmark. It is the annualised standard deviation of the daily difference between the fund's return and the index's return. A low figure means the gap is steady from day to day; it does not say how big the gap is.

The gap comes from the fund's expenses, the cost of buying and selling when the index changes, cash held for redemptions, and the time between a company paying a dividend and the fund reinvesting it.

Tracking differenceis the actual return the investor lost or gained against the index over a period, such as one or three years. It is the figure that shows up in the investor's return. A fund can have a low tracking error and still a steady, larger tracking difference.

What the main indices hold

IndexWhat it holds
Nifty 50
50 stocks
50 of the largest NSE-listed companies
Nifty Next 50
50 stocks
The 50 companies after the Nifty 50 in the Nifty 100
Nifty Midcap 150
150 stocks
Mid-sized companies, after the Nifty 100
Nifty Smallcap 250
250 stocks
Smaller companies, after the Nifty Midcap 150
Nifty 500
500 stocks
The 500 largest companies, all three sizes
BSE Sensex
30 stocks
30 large companies listed on BSE

Weights follow free-float market capitalisation. The index providers publish each index's methodology, constituents and returns on their websites.

Structure

ETF or Index Fund: How They Differ

An ETF and an index fund on the same index hold the same shares. The difference is how they are bought and sold: an ETF trades on the stock exchange during market hours, while an index fund is bought from and sold to the fund house at the day's NAV.

FeatureETFIndex Fund
Expense ratioScheme's own; in the factsheetScheme's own; in the factsheet
Demat accountRequiredNot required
SIPThrough a broker, where offeredAutomatic SIP with the fund house
MinimumOne unit at the market priceScheme's stated minimum
PriceMarket price during trading hours (9:15 am to 3:30 pm)The day's NAV, if the order and money arrive before the cut-off
Other costsBrokerage and the bid-ask spreadExit load, if any
Price versus NAVCan trade above or below NAV; an indicative NAV is publishedAlways the NAV

Where an ETF differs

  • It needs a demat and broking account, and each purchase is an exchange order.
  • The price is known when the order is filled, during market hours.
  • A thinly traded ETF can have a wide bid-ask spread, which is a cost on every trade.
  • Its expense ratio is the scheme's own and may be lower or higher than an index fund's.

Where an index fund differs

  • A SIP runs automatically through a bank mandate, with no demat account.
  • Every purchase and sale is at the day's NAV, so the exact price is not known when the order is placed.
  • There is no brokerage or spread, but an exit load may apply for an early sale.
  • Any amount above the scheme's minimum can be invested, not just whole units.

Nifty 50, Nifty Next 50 and Broader Indices

The Nifty 50 and the Nifty Next 50 together make up the Nifty 100, an index of 100 large companies. The Nifty Next 50 holds companies that are smaller than the Nifty 50 but still among the largest 100; at each review some move up into the Nifty 50 and some drop out.

Because each Nifty 50 company is a large share of a 50-stock index, the Nifty 50 is more concentrated than a broader index. The Nifty Next 50 and the mid and small cap indices have tended to swing more in price, in both directions. The index providers publish the past returns and volatility of every index.

How the indices overlap

Nifty 50 with Nifty Next 50

No overlap: together they are the Nifty 100.

Nifty 50 with Nifty 500

Full overlap for the 50: every Nifty 50 company is also in the Nifty 500.

Nifty Midcap 150 with Nifty Smallcap 250

No overlap: the small cap index starts after the mid cap index.

Nifty 50 with BSE Sensex

Large overlap: most Sensex companies are also in the Nifty 50.

What an Index Fund Does Not Do

Choose shares

It holds what the index holds, including companies whose prices have risen sharply. An active fund may avoid or add companies, which can help or hurt.

Move between asset classes

An equity index fund stays in equity through a market fall. Hybrid and dynamic asset allocation funds change their equity share by their own rules; they are active funds.

Hold things outside the index

Some active funds hold foreign shares or other assets that no single Indian index covers. An index fund holds only its index.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do index funds outperform active mutual funds in India?

An index fund aims to match its index, less its costs; it does not try to beat it. Whether active funds beat their benchmarks is measured by the SPIVA India scorecard, which S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes, by category and period. Its results change from report to report, so the latest scorecard is the source to read. Costs are one fixed difference: an active fund's expense ratio is usually higher, and it must earn that back before it can match the index.

What is tracking error in an index fund?

Tracking error is the annualised standard deviation of the daily difference between the fund's return and the index's return: a measure of how consistently the fund follows the index. Tracking difference is the actual gap between the fund's return and the index's return over a period. SEBI requires index funds and ETFs to disclose both. Between two funds on the same index, lower figures mean closer tracking.

What is the difference between Nifty 50 and Nifty Next 50?

The Nifty 50 holds 50 of the largest companies listed on NSE, weighted by free-float market capitalisation. The Nifty Next 50 holds the 50 companies that come after them within the Nifty 100. Together the two make up the Nifty 100. Companies move between the two indices at the periodic reviews.

Index fund or ETF for Nifty 50 exposure?

Both hold the same shares. An index fund is bought from the fund house at the day's NAV and can run an automatic SIP without a demat account. An ETF is bought and sold on the stock exchange through a broker and needs a demat account; its price moves during the day and can differ slightly from its NAV, and brokerage and the bid-ask spread add to the cost. Expense ratios differ by scheme and are in each factsheet.

What is the minimum investment in an index fund?

Each scheme sets its own minimum for SIP and lumpsum, stated in its scheme information document. An ETF can be bought in a single unit at the exchange price.

How does the Nifty 500 differ from the Nifty 50?

The Nifty 500 holds the 500 largest companies and so includes large, mid and small companies, weighted by free-float market capitalisation. The Nifty 50 companies are part of it, so holding both a Nifty 50 fund and a Nifty 500 fund doubles up on those 50. The broader index carries the larger price swings of smaller companies as well.

How are index fund gains taxed?

An index fund or ETF on an Indian equity index is an equity-oriented fund. Units held more than 12 months give a long-term gain taxed at 12.5% on the year's total above Rs 1,25,000 (Income-tax Act, 2025, section 198); units held 12 months or less give a short-term gain taxed at 20% (section 196).

Calculators

See what a cost difference does over time

Run the SIP calculator twice, at the same rate less each fund's expense ratio, to see what the difference in cost adds up to.