Dismissed from service, is gratuity gone? Section 4(6) of the Gratuity Act and the Supreme Court's Ajay Babu ruling
Dismissal does not automatically forfeit gratuity. How Section 4(6) and the Supreme Court's 2018 Ajay Babu ruling limit forfeiture, how gratuity is taxed, and what a cut does to drawdown.
Key points
- The Supreme Court held on 14 August 2018 in Union Bank of India v. C.G. Ajay Babu that forfeiture of gratuity is not automatic on dismissal.
- Forfeiture for an offence involving moral turpitude needs a court conviction, and loss-based forfeiture is capped at the quantified loss.
- A dismissed employee can challenge a forfeiture order, and a Rs 2 lakh cut can leave a 10-year drawdown almost empty.

Photo: Subhashish Panigrahi / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped). File photo.
An employee dismissed after 25 years of service often assumes the gratuity went with the job. The Supreme Court said otherwise on 14 August 2018. In Union Bank of India v. C.G. Ajay Babu, Civil Appeal No. 8251 of 2018, reported at (2018) 9 SCC 529, a bench of Justice Kurian Joseph and Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul held in paragraph 22 that "forfeiture of gratuity is not automatic on dismissal from service". It is subject to sub-sections (5) and (6) of Section 4 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, and those sub-sections set conditions an employer must actually meet.
This piece walks through what Section 4(6) allows, what the bank in that case did wrong, how gratuity is taxed when it is finally paid, and what a forfeiture of even Rs 2 lakh does to a retirement drawdown over 10 years. The full judgment is on Indian Kanoon.
The Scheme Explained
What gratuity is and how it is calculated
Section 4(1) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 makes gratuity payable when employment ends after at least 5 years of continuous service, whether by superannuation, retirement, resignation, or death or disablement. The 5-year condition does not apply on death or disablement. For an employee covered by the Act, gratuity is 15 days' wages for every completed year of service, worked out as last drawn basic pay plus dearness allowance x 15 x years of service / 26. Our Gratuity Calculator runs this formula, and the gratuity glossary entry explains the terms.
Take a branch officer with 25 years of service and last drawn basic plus DA of Rs 60,000 a month. Gratuity under the Act is Rs 60,000 x 15 x 25 / 26, or Rs 8,65,385. The ceiling on gratuity payable under the Act is Rs 20 lakh, so this figure is well inside it.
The three forfeiture routes in Section 4(6)
Section 4(6) opens with "notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1)", which is why it can cut into a right that has otherwise vested. It contains three separate grounds, and the Supreme Court stressed in paragraph 16 of Ajay Babu that clauses (a) and (b) "operate in different fields and in different circumstances".
| Clause | Ground for termination | How much can be forfeited | What the employer must show |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4(6)(a) | Act, wilful omission or negligence causing damage or loss to, or destruction of, the employer's property | Only "to the extent of the damage or loss so caused" | A quantified loss linked to the act |
| 4(6)(b)(i) | Riotous or disorderly conduct, or any other act of violence | Wholly or partially | Termination for that conduct |
| 4(6)(b)(ii) | An act that constitutes an offence involving moral turpitude, committed in the course of employment | Wholly or partially | Conviction by a competent court (para 18) |
What happened in Ajay Babu
The respondent was a branch manager of Union Bank of India. Departmental charges, including failure to protect the bank's interest and acts "unbecoming of an Officer Employee", were proved, and he was dismissed on 3 June 2004. The dismissal itself became final. Before that, a show-cause notice dated 30 January 2004 asked why his gratuity should not be forfeited for "proved misconduct involving moral turpitude". By an order dated 20 April 2004, the bank forfeited Rs 1,77,900 of his gratuity, citing Section 4(6)(b)(ii) of the Act and clause 3 of Schedule A of its own gratuity rules.
The High Court, by a Single Judge judgment dated 8 January 2016, upheld the dismissal but set aside the forfeiture, and the bank appealed. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal on two independent grounds.
Ground 1: "conduct" is not an "offence". In paragraph 18, the court said it is "not the conduct of a person involving moral turpitude that is required for forfeiture of gratuity but the conduct or the act should constitute an offence involving moral turpitude". Relying on the definition of "offence" in the General Clauses Act, 1897 (paragraph 17), it held that whether an offence was committed "is absolutely in the realm of criminal law. It is not for the Bank to decide whether an offence has been committed. It is for the court." The bank had filed no FIR and no criminal complaint. Forfeiture under clause (b)(ii) therefore needs a conviction by a court of competent jurisdiction. Paragraph 19 followed Jaswant Singh Gill v. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd., (2007) 1 SCC 663, which had read the same requirement into the Act.
Ground 2: better terms under an agreement prevail. Section 4(5) preserves an employee's right to "better terms of gratuity under any award or agreement or contract". The bank's bipartite settlement of 19 August 1966 said, in clause 12.2, that there would be no forfeiture for dismissal "except in cases where such misconduct causes financial loss to the bank and in that case to that extent only". Paragraph 15 records that the bank never claimed the employee had caused it any financial loss. Paragraphs 12 to 14, following Beed District Central Coop. Bank Ltd., (2006) 8 SCC 514, held that the employee chooses either the agreement or the statute as a whole.
Paragraph 21 added a third point: the Act prevails over an employer's own gratuity rules, so a bank cannot rely on its internal rules to deny what the Act grants.
Where the law stands after 21 November 2025
The four labour codes, including the Code on Social Security, 2020, came into force on 21 November 2025, and the Code now houses the gratuity provisions that sat in the 1972 Act. The Ajay Babu reasoning turns on the difference between misconduct and a proved criminal offence, a distinction that does not depend on a section number. Anyone whose employment ended after that date should still read the forfeiture clause in the Code itself, alongside the 1972 text cited in this article, before relying on any single paragraph.
Tax on Withdrawal
Gratuity that is eventually paid, whether on time or after years of litigation, is taxed under the head "Salaries". The exemption depends on who the employer is, and the Income Tax Department's guide for salaried individuals lists gratuity as an exempt allowance subject to these limits.
| Type of employee | Exemption under Section 10(10), Income-tax Act, 1961 | Taxable portion |
|---|---|---|
| Central or state government employee | Fully exempt under Section 10(10)(i) | Nil |
| Non-government, covered by the Payment of Gratuity Act | Least of: gratuity under the Act formula, Rs 20 lakh, or the amount actually received | Excess over the exempt amount, at slab rates |
| Non-government, not covered by the Act | Least of: half-month's average salary per completed year, Rs 20 lakh, or the amount actually received | Excess over the exempt amount, at slab rates |
The Rs 20 lakh limit is a lifetime ceiling across all employers, set by the Finance Act, 2018 amendment to Section 10(10). It is not Rs 25 lakh. For tax year 2026-27 onwards, the Income-tax Act, 2025 has replaced the 1961 Act, so a payment received after 1 April 2026 is claimed under the corresponding provision of the new law. The Rs 20 lakh ceiling used in this article is the one fixed under Section 10(10).
For our branch officer, the Rs 8,65,385 is below the Rs 20 lakh ceiling and equals the Act formula amount, so the whole sum is exempt. If Rs 2,00,000 were lawfully forfeited under Section 4(6)(a), the Rs 6,65,385 actually received would be the lowest of the three limits and would also be fully exempt. A forfeiture therefore costs the employee the gross amount, with no tax offset.
What the employee does with the money afterwards is taxed separately. Interest from a bank FD, a post office deposit or the Senior Citizens' Savings Scheme is "income from other sources" and taxed at slab rates, often with TDS deducted at source. Under the new regime for FY 2025-26 onwards, the slabs are nil up to Rs 4 lakh, 5% from Rs 4 lakh to Rs 8 lakh, 10% from Rs 8 lakh to Rs 12 lakh, 15% from Rs 12 lakh to Rs 16 lakh, 20% from Rs 16 lakh to Rs 20 lakh, 25% from Rs 20 lakh to Rs 24 lakh and 30% above Rs 24 lakh, plus 4% health and education cess. The Section 87A rebate in the new regime is up to Rs 60,000 for total income up to Rs 12 lakh, and salaried and pension income gets a Rs 75,000 standard deduction.
Worked Drawdown
The cost of a forfeiture is not only the amount taken. It is the income that amount would have produced in retirement. The illustrations below use the Rs 8,65,385 gratuity from earlier and a return of 8.2% a year, which is the Senior Citizens' Savings Scheme rate for October to December 2026 (Q3 FY 2026-27). SCSS has its own age and deposit rules and pays interest rather than compounding it, so treat 8.2% here as an illustrative rate rather than a product recommendation. The employee withdraws Rs 1,00,000 at the end of every year, roughly Rs 8,333 a month.
Scenario A is Ajay Babu: no quantified loss, no conviction, so no lawful forfeiture and the full Rs 8,65,385 is paid. Scenario B assumes the employer proves and quantifies a loss of Rs 2,00,000 under Section 4(6)(a) and forfeits exactly that, leaving Rs 6,65,385.
| Year | A: return earned | A: closing corpus | B: return earned | B: closing corpus |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rs 70,962 | Rs 8,36,347 | Rs 54,562 | Rs 6,19,947 |
| 2 | Rs 68,580 | Rs 8,04,927 | Rs 50,836 | Rs 5,70,782 |
| 3 | Rs 66,004 | Rs 7,70,931 | Rs 46,804 | Rs 5,17,586 |
| 4 | Rs 63,216 | Rs 7,34,147 | Rs 42,442 | Rs 4,60,028 |
| 5 | Rs 60,200 | Rs 6,94,347 | Rs 37,722 | Rs 3,97,751 |
| 6 | Rs 56,936 | Rs 6,51,284 | Rs 32,616 | Rs 3,30,366 |
| 7 | Rs 53,405 | Rs 6,04,689 | Rs 27,090 | Rs 2,57,456 |
| 8 | Rs 49,585 | Rs 5,54,274 | Rs 21,111 | Rs 1,78,568 |
| 9 | Rs 45,450 | Rs 4,99,724 | Rs 14,643 | Rs 93,210 |
| 10 | Rs 40,977 | Rs 4,40,702 | Rs 7,643 | Rs 854 |
After 10 years of identical Rs 1,00,000 withdrawals, Scenario A still holds Rs 4,40,702. Scenario B is down to Rs 854, so the Rs 2,00,000 forfeiture has cost Rs 4,39,848 of closing corpus. The difference is larger than the forfeiture because the lost Rs 2,00,000 would have earned 8.2% every year, starting with Rs 16,400 in year 1.
The amount in Ajay Babu was Rs 1,77,900. At the same 8.2%, that sum alone would earn Rs 14,588 a year, or Rs 1,45,878 in simple interest over 10 years. You can test other withdrawal rates in the Retirement Drawdown calculator, compare the gratuity in an annuity against a systematic withdrawal plan with the Annuity vs SWP calculator, and see SCSS payouts in the SCSS calculator.
On tax, Scenario A's highest annual return, Rs 70,962 in year 1, would be taxable at slab rates. A retiree in the new regime whose total income, including this interest, stays at or below Rs 12 lakh pays nothing after the Rs 60,000 Section 87A rebate. For example, a Rs 6,00,000 pension less the Rs 75,000 standard deduction, plus Rs 70,962 of interest, gives taxable income of Rs 5,95,962, and the tax of Rs 9,798 at 5% on the slice above Rs 4 lakh is wiped out by the rebate.
What a dismissed employee can do
- Ask for the forfeiture order in writing and check which clause of Section 4(6) it cites. Ajay Babu turned on an order that cited clause (b)(ii) without a conviction.
- If clause (a) is cited, check whether the loss has been quantified. Jaswant Singh Gill, quoted at paragraph 19, noted that the disciplinary authority there "has not quantified the loss or damage".
- If clause (b)(ii) is cited, check whether any criminal court has convicted you. Paragraph 18 says an FIR or complaint must set the criminal law in motion; a departmental finding is not enough.
- Read your service settlement, award or contract. Under Section 4(5), a clause like the bank's 1966 settlement can narrow forfeiture further than the Act does.
- Raise the claim with the controlling authority under Section 7 of the Act, which requires payment within 30 days of gratuity becoming payable.
FAQ
Does dismissal from service automatically forfeit gratuity?
No. Paragraph 22 of Union Bank of India v. C.G. Ajay Babu, decided on 14 August 2018, holds that forfeiture "is not automatic on dismissal from service" and is subject to Sections 4(5) and 4(6) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
Can an employer forfeit gratuity for misconduct involving moral turpitude proved in a departmental inquiry?
Not under Section 4(6)(b)(ii) on that basis alone. The Supreme Court held in paragraphs 18 and 20 that the act must constitute an offence involving moral turpitude, committed in the course of employment, and established by conviction in a court of competent jurisdiction.
How much gratuity can be forfeited if I caused a financial loss?
Under Section 4(6)(a), only "to the extent of the damage or loss so caused". If the loss is Rs 2,00,000 and gratuity is Rs 8,65,385, the employer can forfeit Rs 2,00,000, not the full amount, and must quantify the loss first.
Can my employer's own gratuity rules allow wider forfeiture than the Act?
No. Paragraph 21 of Ajay Babu, following Jaswant Singh Gill (2007) 1 SCC 663, says the Act prevails over rules framed by the employer. An agreement can only give better terms under Section 4(5), as the bank's 1966 settlement did.
Is gratuity received after winning a forfeiture dispute taxable?
For a non-government employee covered by the Act, it is exempt up to the least of the Act formula amount, Rs 20 lakh, or the amount received, under Section 10(10) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. Government employees' gratuity is fully exempt under Section 10(10)(i).
What is the maximum gratuity payable under the Act?
The ceiling under the Payment of Gratuity Act is Rs 20 lakh, which matches the Rs 20 lakh lifetime tax exemption limit under Section 10(10). It is not Rs 25 lakh.
This article explains the Supreme Court ruling of 14 August 2018 and general tax rules. It is not legal or tax advice. Gratuity disputes depend on the exact order, service terms and facts of each case.
Sources & Citations
- Union Bank of India vs C.G. Ajay Babu, 14 August 2018 — Supreme Court of India (Indian Kanoon)
- Salaried Individuals for AY 2026-27 — Income Tax Department