Annuity vs SWP: How the Two Retirement Income Options Compare
A retirement corpus can be turned into a monthly income in two main ways: by buying an annuity from a life insurer, which pays a fixed income for life or for a set period, or by running a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) from mutual fund units, which sells units each month to pay a chosen amount. This calculator puts the two side by side for the same corpus and shows the income after tax, the effect of inflation and how long the SWP corpus lasts at the return entered.
How an Annuity Works
An annuity is a contract with a life insurer registered with IRDAI. The buyer pays a lump sum, the purchase price, and the insurer pays an income at the rate fixed at the time of purchase. The main types are a life annuity, which pays for life and stops on death; a life annuity with return of purchase price, which pays a lower income and returns the purchase price to the nominee on death; a joint life last survivor annuity, which pays until the second of two spouses dies; and annuities with payouts that rise by a fixed percentage each year. The rate depends on the buyer's age, the type of annuity and interest rates when it is bought; the insurer's quote and policy document set it. A conventional annuity pays the same amount every year.
How an SWP Works
An SWP redeems mutual fund units at fixed intervals to pay a set amount. The rest of the corpus stays invested, so its value moves with the market. If the withdrawals are larger than what the portfolio earns over time, the corpus runs down; if they are smaller, it can grow. The amount can be changed or stopped, and what is left on death passes to the nominee or legal heirs.
How the Calculator Works
The annuity income is the corpus multiplied by the annuity rate entered. The SWP withdraws the monthly amount entered each year, grows the rest at the return entered and stops when the corpus runs out, up to 60 years. Both rates are the reader's inputs; the calculator does not predict them. With the default inputs (a Rs 1 crore corpus, a 6.5% annuity rate, a 10% SWP return, a Rs 50,000 monthly withdrawal, a 30% tax rate, 6% inflation and an NPS annuity), the annuity pays Rs 54,167 a month before tax and Rs 37,917 after tax. The SWP pays Rs 50,000 a month, Rs 46,157 a month on average after the calculator's estimate of capital gains tax, and the corpus lasts more than 60 years at 10%; at a 6% return it lasts 50 years. After 20 years of 6% inflation, the annuity's Rs 37,917 buys what Rs 11,823 buys today.
Tax for Tax Year 2026-27
Annuity. An annuity payout is income in the year it is received and is taxed at the buyer's slab rate. Under the new regime in section 202 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, the rates are nil up to Rs 4 lakh, 5% from Rs 4 to 8 lakh, 10% from Rs 8 to 12 lakh, 15% from Rs 12 to 16 lakh, 20% from Rs 16 to 20 lakh, 25% from Rs 20 to 24 lakh and 30% above Rs 24 lakh, and the rebate in section 156 removes the tax on total income up to Rs 12 lakh. The old regime's rates come from the Finance Act, 2026.
SWP. Each withdrawal is a sale of units, so only the gain in it is taxed, not the whole amount. For an equity-oriented fund, long-term gains are taxed at 12.5% on gains above Rs 1,25,000 in a year under section 198(2), and short-term gains at 20% under section 196(1). The calculator applies the long-term rate to every year's gain and does not model other fund types, which are taxed under different rules.
Inflation and Longevity
A level annuity pays the same rupee amount every year, so what it buys falls with inflation: at 6% a year, Rs 50,000 buys what about Rs 15,590 buys today after 20 years. An SWP withdrawal can be raised each year, but a larger withdrawal runs the corpus down faster. A life annuity keeps paying however long the annuitant lives, which an SWP cannot promise; an SWP leaves the unspent corpus to the heirs, which a life annuity without return of purchase price does not.
NPS Annuity
At normal exit, at least 20% of the NPS corpus (40% for government-sector subscribers) must be used to buy an annuity, under the PFRDA exit regulations as amended from 16 December 2025. A corpus up to Rs 8 lakh can be withdrawn in full. The annuity is bought from a life insurer registered with IRDAI and empanelled by the Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority (PFRDA) as an Annuity Service Provider.
The pension from the NPS annuity is income in the year it is received (section 124(6)(b) of the Income-tax Act, 2025). The lump sum is tax-free up to 60% of the corpus (Schedule II, Sl. No. 6); anything withdrawn above 60% is income (section 124(6)(a)). The lump sum can be invested elsewhere, including in mutual funds run as an SWP.
What the Comparison Depends On
The result turns on the inputs: the annuity rate quoted, the return the SWP portfolio earns and the order in which good and bad years come, the tax rate on each kind of income, inflation, how long the money is needed, and whether any of the corpus is meant for heirs. Other guaranteed income, such as a pension or the Senior Citizens' Savings Scheme, changes how much of the monthly need each option has to meet. A corpus can also be split between the two.