NCDRC rejects Buldana co-operative bank's Rs 77.63 lakh claim against New India Assurance
The NCDRC upheld New India Assurance's rejection of Buldana District Central Cooperative Bank's Rs 77.63 lakh indemnity claim, holding the bank did not show it met policy conditions.
Key points
- The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission dismissed Buldana District Central Cooperative Bank's appeal against New India Assurance on 18 November 2026.
- The bank had claimed Rs 77,63,745 under a bankers indemnity policy for losses at its Matargaon branch that it alleged its employees caused in 1999-2001.
- The commission held the bank did not prove job rotation or reviews of internal controls, which the policy made conditions for the insurer's liability.
The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) has upheld New India Assurance's rejection of a Rs 77,63,745 claim by Buldana District Central Cooperative Bank under a bankers indemnity insurance policy. In an order dated 18 November 2026, the NCDRC dismissed the bank's appeal against a 4 November 2015 order of the Maharashtra State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission.
What Happened
According to the order, the bank alleged that between 1999 and 2001 four employees at its Matargaon branch caused it losses of Rs 77,63,745 through cash taken in transit, forged or altered withdrawal vouchers, fixed deposit money collected from depositors but not deposited, and cash deposits left out of the books. The bank also sought interest at 18% a year and Rs 1 crore in damages. New India Assurance rejected the claim on 29 October 2007, saying the bank had not complied with Clause 5 of the policy, which set conditions that had to be met before the insurer became liable.
Those conditions included job rotation for employees handling money, dual control, and a review of internal controls at least once in two financial years at every branch, in addition to the statutory audit. The NCDRC found that the bank's own posting records showed some of the employees stayed at the Matargaon branch for long periods, and that the bank produced no record of the required reviews. It noted that a special audit report of 10 May 2002 recorded deficiencies in internal controls at the branch.
The commission held that a surveyor's assessment of the loss did not prove the conditions were met, and that the bank's complaint about not receiving the surveyor's report did not change its obligation to prove compliance. It said the bank could not rely on IRDAI policyholder regulations made in 2002 for events of 1999-2001. The parties will bear their own costs.
What It Means
The ruling shows that cover under a bankers indemnity policy can depend on the bank following the policy's internal-control conditions, and that the insured must prove it did. The order does not say how the criminal proceedings against the employees ended; allegations are not findings of guilt, and the accused are presumed innocent until proven guilty in court. The NCDRC's order may be appealed to the Supreme Court.
Source: Consumer commission order
Sources & Citations
- Consumer commission order — Consumer commission