OquiliaOquilia
Enforcement

SEBI cancels Rs 93.61 lakh Bodhtree recovery after SAT sets aside penalty

SEBI has cancelled a Rs 93.61 lakh recovery certificate in the Bodhtree Consulting matter after the Securities Appellate Tribunal set aside a Rs 90 lakh fraud penalty.

Key points

  • SEBI cancelled Recovery Certificate No. 4948 of 2022 against two Bodhtree directors and Kepler Information Systems on 18 November 2026.
  • The Rs 93.61 lakh demand followed a Rs 90 lakh fraud penalty that the Securities Appellate Tribunal set aside on 6 October 2026.
  • Smaller penalties for breaking employee share scheme rules were upheld, and SEBI can still appeal the ruling to the Supreme Court.
Oquilia Newsroom
Financial news desk covering SEBI, RBI, IRDAI, and Budget-related developments.
8 min read · 1,680 words
Verified Sources
Enforcement / 20 Nov 2026

The Enforcement Action

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has cancelled a recovery certificate for Rs 93.61 lakh that it had drawn up against L Muneashwari, L Naga Rama Krishna and Kepler Information Systems Private Limited in the matter of Bodhtree Consulting Limited. The cancellation notice was signed by the Recovery Officer at SEBI's Southern Regional Office in Chennai on 18 November 2026.

Recovery Certificate No. 4948 of 2022, dated 20 June 2022, was issued for Rs 93,61,000 plus interest, costs and charges. According to the notice, it was raised for non-payment of a penalty imposed by SEBI's Adjudicating Officer in AO Order No. Order/MC/HP/2021-2022/15372-15392 dated 15 March 2022.

The notice says the certificate is cancelled "in view of the Order of the Hon'ble Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) dated October 06, 2026, in Appeal No. 447/2022". The power used is sub-section (1) of Section 28A of the SEBI Act, 1992, read with Section 413 of the Income-Tax Act, 2025.

That SAT ruling is what matters here. The tribunal set aside the Rs 90 lakh penalty that SEBI had imposed on the three parties under the fraud provisions of securities law. It upheld smaller penalties for breaking the rules on employee share schemes. In plain terms, the fraud finding behind the largest part of the demand no longer stands.

How the Scheme Worked

The March 2022 adjudication order covered 21 noticees. It followed a SEBI investigation into Bodhtree Consulting Limited, a Hyderabad IT services company listed on BSE, for the period 2 March 2017 to 26 March 2018. The investigation began after an alert that a former employee had sold 94,000 Bodhtree shares worth Rs 88.67 lakh on 7 February 2018.

The order set out the following sequence. Bodhtree's employee welfare trust, formed in 2003, transferred 1,00,000 shares free of cost to the employee on 22 February 2017. A year later he moved 6,000 shares to Kepler Information Systems off-market and sold the other 94,000 on the exchange. Of the Rs 87.69 lakh he received, Rs 82 lakh went within days to three people described in the order as relatives of Bodhtree's managing director. They in turn passed Rs 72.50 lakh to Kepler.

SEBI's Adjudicating Officer found that Kepler was 99.57% held by L Naga Rama Krishna, Bodhtree's managing director, and L Muneashwari, a director of both companies. The officer held that "the wealth of shareholders of the listed entity was transferred to a private entity". He imposed Rs 90 lakh under Section 15HA of the SEBI Act, payable jointly and severally by the three. He also imposed Rs 5 lakh on L Naga Rama Krishna and Rs 1 lakh on L Muneashwari under Section 15HB. Penalties across all noticees came to Rs 1.21 crore.

The procedural history, according to the two orders, ran as follows. SEBI appointed the Adjudicating Officer on 29 June 2020 and served a show-cause notice on 12 November 2020. The adjudication order followed on 15 March 2022, and the certificate on 20 June 2022. SAT reserved the appeal on 2 September 2026 and ruled on 6 October 2026.

Before the tribunal, the appellants argued that the employee's loans were private and interest-bearing, backed by promissory notes. They said the loans had no link to the securities market. They added that SEBI had not shown any price manipulation or any investor who was induced to trade. SEBI's counsel conceded there was no price or volume manipulation. He argued instead that the transactions moved shareholder wealth to Kepler and noted that the loans had largely not been repaid.

The tribunal agreed with the appellants on fraud. It held that the share allotment was not deceitful, since two other employees received shares on the same criteria. It also held that the sale took place on the exchange at market price, and that the loans were "independent private financial transactions". It found that the shares held by the trust were not Bodhtree's assets, so the claim of a transfer of shareholder wealth was "unfounded".

The Law Invoked

The 2022 order applied Section 15HA of the SEBI Act, the penalty for fraudulent and unfair trade practices, for breaches of Regulations 3(a), (b), (c), (d) and 4(1) of the SEBI (Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices relating to Securities Market) Regulations, 2003, read with Section 12A(a)(b)(c) of the SEBI Act. These provisions ban manipulative or deceptive devices and fraud in connection with dealing in securities. Section 15HA, as quoted in the order, carries a minimum penalty of Rs 5 lakh.

It also applied Section 15HB, a general penalty for breaking SEBI rules where no specific penalty is provided. This covered breaches of the SEBI (Share Based Employee Benefits) Regulations, 2014. Regulation 3(4) bars a company's directors and key managerial staff from being trustees of its employee benefit trust. Regulation 3(6) requires trustees to make sure shareholders have approved the scheme. SEBI's January 2013 circular CIR/CFD/DIL/3/2013 and later circulars required older employee trusts to align with the 1999 ESOP guidelines or sell their shares.

SAT upheld the Section 15HB penalties, finding that the company and its trust never brought the scheme into line with these rules. It described the failure to align the scheme as "only a technical violation". On fraud, it followed the Supreme Court's ruling in Reliance Industries Ltd. v. SEBI, which holds that inducing another person to deal in securities remains a strict requirement for fraud.

What Happens Next

The cancellation removes the recovery certificate as a basis for attaching the parties' bank accounts, demat holdings or property for the Rs 93.61 lakh demand. SAT also upheld Section 15HB penalties of Rs 1 lakh on L Muneashwari and Rs 5 lakh on L Naga Rama Krishna. The cancellation notice does not say how those surviving amounts will be dealt with, and SEBI has not published anything further on this.

An appeal against a SAT order lies to the Supreme Court. Nothing in SEBI's notice says whether the regulator intends to challenge the 6 October 2026 ruling. In practice, SEBI cancelling the certificate "in view of" that order shows it is giving effect to the ruling for now.

Two other strands of the matter are settled, according to the SAT order. The tribunal dismissed Bodhtree's own appeal on 4 December 2025, noting that the company had paid its Rs 8 lakh penalty and is in the corporate insolvency resolution process. The Section 15HA penalty on the other appellants, including the former employee and the three relatives, was also set aside.

What It Means

For investors, the case shows that a SEBI adjudication order is not always the last word. The Securities Appellate Tribunal reviews findings in full, and a large share of a penalty can fall away on appeal. Recovery certificates, attachments and SEBI's lists of defaulters can change after a tribunal ruling. Anyone tracking a SEBI matter should read the latest order, not the first headline.

The ruling also clarifies what SEBI must prove to establish fraud. Following the Supreme Court, SAT held that loans to relatives of a managing director, paid from shares sold at market price, do not on their own amount to fraud in securities. The regulator needs evidence of deceptive dealing in securities, or of investors being induced to trade.

The parts that survived matter for shareholders too. Employee welfare trusts holding a company's own shares must follow the SEBI (Share Based Employee Benefits) Regulations, 2014: independent trustees, shareholder approval and proper disclosure. Shareholders can check a company's annual report and its shareholding filings on BSE or NSE for any employee trust holding, and whether shareholders approved the scheme by special resolution.

FAQ

What exactly did SEBI do on 18 November 2026?

SEBI's Recovery Officer at the Southern Regional Office cancelled Recovery Certificate No. 4948 of 2022. The certificate sought Rs 93,61,000 plus interest and costs from L Muneashwari, L Naga Rama Krishna and Kepler Information Systems Private Limited. The cancellation was made in view of the Securities Appellate Tribunal's order of 6 October 2026 in Appeal No. 447/2022, using powers under Section 28A(1) of the SEBI Act, 1992, read with Section 413 of the Income-Tax Act, 2025.

Does this mean the people named committed fraud?

No. SEBI's Adjudicating Officer found a breach of the fraud regulations in March 2022, but the Securities Appellate Tribunal set that finding and the Rs 90 lakh penalty aside on 6 October 2026. It held that the charge under the PFUTP Regulations read with Section 12A "is not sustainable". What survives are smaller penalties under Section 15HB for breaking the rules on employee share schemes, which the tribunal called a technical violation.

Which penalties still stand?

According to the SAT order, Section 15HB penalties were upheld for L Muneashwari (Rs 1 lakh) and L Naga Rama Krishna (Rs 5 lakh), along with two trustees of the employee trust. Bodhtree Consulting's Rs 8 lakh penalty was paid, and its appeal was dismissed in December 2025. All Section 15HA fraud penalties under the 2022 order were set aside.

Can SEBI challenge the tribunal's ruling?

Yes. An appeal against a Securities Appellate Tribunal order lies to the Supreme Court of India. SEBI's cancellation notice does not mention any appeal. If SEBI does challenge the ruling and succeeds, the original demand could be revived. Until then, the tribunal's order governs and the recovery certificate stays cancelled.

Where can I read the official documents?

The cancellation notice and the March 2022 adjudication order are both on SEBI's website under Enforcement, in the Recovery Proceedings and Orders of AO sections respectively. The Securities Appellate Tribunal's judgment of 6 October 2026 in Appeal No. 447 of 2022 is available on Indian Kanoon. The links are at the end of this report.

This report is based on the official SEBI notice dated 18 November 2026 cancelling Recovery Certificate No. 4948 of 2022, the SEBI adjudication order of 15 March 2022 and the Securities Appellate Tribunal order of 6 October 2026.

This report describes enforcement actions and allegations on the public record, attributed to the officials cited. An order, FIR or chargesheet is not a conviction; parties are presumed innocent until proven guilty.

Named in this report, or spotted an error? Corrections and responses: editor@oquilia.com. We correct errors promptly and record responses from named parties.

Sources & Citations

  1. Cancellation of Recovery Certificate No. 4948 of 2022 in the matter of Bodhtree Consulting Limited — SEBI
  2. Adjudication Order in respect of 21 entities in the matter of Bodhtree Consulting Limited — SEBI
  3. Mr. Hassan Ali & Others vs SEBI, Securities Appellate Tribunal, 6 October 2026 — Securities Appellate Tribunal

This article was last reviewed on 20 November 2026 by Oquilia's editorial team. Every claim is sourced from primary regulatory materials (CBDT, IRDAI, RBI, SEBI, Indian Kanoon). View our methodology.

Found an error? Report an issue.