SAT dismisses investor's appeal over Rs 38.64 lakh lost in WhatsApp impersonation scam
The Securities Appellate Tribunal upheld SEBI's closure of an investor's SCORES complaints, holding that he was a victim of cybercrime and that the broker whose name was used had not broken the circulars cited.
Key points
- The Securities Appellate Tribunal on 16 November 2026 dismissed an investor's appeal against SEBI's closure of his SCORES complaints.
- The investor had transferred Rs 38,64,500 to third-party bank accounts on instructions given in a WhatsApp group, the order records.
- SAT held he was a victim of cybercrime and that no money went to Aditya Birla Money, whose name the group had used.
The Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) on 16 November 2026 dismissed an appeal by an investor who lost Rs 38,64,500 after following instructions in a WhatsApp group whose members claimed to represent Aditya Birla Money Limited. The tribunal upheld SEBI's decision to close his complaints on SCORES, SEBI's online complaint system, holding that he was a victim of cybercrime.
What Happened
According to the order, the investor was added to a WhatsApp group in which some people presented themselves as members of Aditya Birla Money's capital management team. Acting on their instructions, he made seven transfers between 18 December 2024 and 18 January 2025 to bank accounts they supplied. He received no confirmation from the broker, and on asking it he learned that it had already filed a police complaint about the fake groups.
He argued that the broker should have issued a public notice under an NSE circular on impersonation and should have reported the matter to CERT-In under SEBI's cyber security circular of 20 August 2024. SAT rejected both points. It noted that the broker's website carried a warning against fraudulent calls, SMS, emails, WhatsApp and Telegram messages using its name, and held that this was a sufficient caution. It said the reporting duty to CERT-In covers phishing websites, while this case involved WhatsApp messages. The order records that none of the money was transferred to Aditya Birla Money and that the investor did not check the broker's official website before paying third parties. SAT's order may be appealed to the Supreme Court.
What It Means
The ruling shows that a broker whose name is misused by impersonators may not be held responsible when money goes to accounts that have nothing to do with it. Before transferring money for any investment, check the intermediary's registration on SEBI's website and pay only into accounts in the broker's own name, using its official app or website. Treat any WhatsApp or Telegram group offering trading tips and asking for transfers with caution. If you have been cheated, report it at once at https://cybercrime.gov.in or on helpline 1930; complaints against SEBI-registered intermediaries can be filed at https://scores.sebi.gov.in.
Source: SAT order
Sources & Citations
- SAT order — Securities Appellate Tribunal