Chandigarh consumer commission upholds JCB damage claim against New India Assurance
The Chandigarh State Consumer Commission dismissed New India Assurance's appeal and upheld an order to pay Rs 3.32 lakh with 6% interest on a JCB damage claim it had rejected.
Key points
- The State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, UT Chandigarh, dismissed New India Assurance's appeal on 16 November 2026.
- The insurer must pay Rs 3,31,898 assessed by its own surveyor, with 6% interest from 6 May 2020, plus Rs 20,000.
- The commission held an insurer cannot set aside its own surveyor's findings without evidence; the order may be appealed.

Photo: Blogtrepreneur / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 (cropped). Representational image.
The State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, UT Chandigarh, on 16 November 2026 dismissed an appeal by The New India Assurance Company Limited and upheld an order to pay a vehicle owner Rs 3,31,898.54 for accident damage to an insured JCB. The insurer must also pay 6% annual interest from 6 May 2020 and Rs 20,000 as compensation and litigation costs.
What Happened
The JCB was insured for the period from 27 June 2019 to 26 June 2020, for an insured declared value of Rs 24,41,500. It met with an accident on 3 October 2019. The owner paid Rs 4,60,448 for repairs, but the insurer rejected the claim on 6 May 2020, saying the vehicle was not duly registered on the day of the accident and that the driver's licence did not cover construction equipment.
The commission held that the tax for permanent registration had been deposited at 11:57 am that day, before the accident, and that a delay by the registering authority in issuing the certificate could not be used to defeat the claim. On the licence, it held that the insurer had neither pleaded nor proved that the JCB's unladen weight exceeded 7,500 kg, the limit up to which an ordinary light motor vehicle licence applies, per the judgments it relied on.
The commission also noted that the insurer's own surveyor had found the damage consistent with the accident and assessed the loss at Rs 3,31,898.54. An investigator's contrary opinion could not override that assessment, it held. The District Commission had already restricted the award to the surveyor's figure.
What It Means
For policyholders, the order says an insurer cannot rely on its surveyor's figure to limit what it pays while rejecting the same report's findings on the accident, unless it shows the report is wrong. Where registration fees were paid before an accident, a later certificate date was not a valid ground for rejection in this case.
The order is the commission's finding and may be appealed. Policyholders whose claims are rejected can call the National Consumer Helpline on 1915 or file a complaint through e-Daakhil.
Source: Consumer commission order
Sources & Citations
- Consumer commission order — Consumer commission