OquiliaOquilia
Tax

ITAT Hyderabad deletes Rs 24.1 lakh tax addition on housing society, cites consistency

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in Hyderabad deleted a Rs 24,10,110 addition to a co-operative housing society's income, holding the tax officer could not depart from the view accepted a year earlier.

Key points

  • The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad, on 6 November 2026 allowed a co-operative housing society's appeal for assessment year 2017-18.
  • The tax officer had assessed the society's income at Rs 24,10,110 from rent, interest and lease income, though its accounts showed a net loss.
  • The tribunal held that without a change in law or facts, the tax officer could not take a view different from the one accepted for 2016-17.
Oquilia Newsroom
Financial news desk covering SEBI, RBI, IRDAI, and Budget-related developments.
2 min read · 369 wordsहिन्दी में पढ़ें
Verified SourcesSource: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal
Two residential towers under construction with tower cranes, behind a green lawn

Photo: Biswarup Ganguly / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0 (cropped). Representational image.

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) in Hyderabad on 6 November 2026 deleted an addition of Rs 24,10,110 to the income of IDPL Employees Cooperative House Building Society Limited for assessment year 2017-18. The tribunal held that the tax officer could not take a different view from the one the department had accepted for the previous year.

What Happened

The society filed its return in October 2017 declaring a net loss. In scrutiny, the assessing officer taxed Rs 11,73,634 as income from house property and Rs 12,36,473 as income from other sources, a total of Rs 24,10,110. The first appellate authority upheld this in an order dated 29 December 2025.

The society argued that its receipts were used for the mutual benefit of its members, and that its accounts showed an overall loss. The tax department's representative argued that the principle of mutuality, the idea that a body does not earn taxable income from dealings with its own members, does not cover rent, bank deposit interest and lease rent from vacant land.

The tribunal found that the assessing officer had not disputed that the society's overall result for the year, including the rent, interest and lease income, was a loss of Rs 32,00,078. Once the net result is a loss, taxing the other income while leaving out the loss from the society's normal activity was unjustified, it held.

It also noted that for assessment year 2016-17, the assessing officer had scrutinised the same issue and accepted the society's claim in an order dated 24 December 2018. Under the rule of consistency, without any change in law or facts, the officer could not take a different view unless that earlier order was disturbed, the tribunal held. It allowed the appeal and deleted the addition.

What It Means

For housing societies and other taxpayers, the order applies a settled idea: when the tax department has accepted a treatment in a scrutiny assessment for one year, the tribunal held that the officer cannot reverse it for the next year on the same facts without a change in law or facts. The department's arguments on mutuality were held not to apply where the society's net result was a loss.

Source: ITAT order

Sources & Citations

  1. ITAT order — Income Tax Appellate Tribunal

This article was last reviewed on 16 November 2026 by Oquilia's editorial team. Every claim is sourced from primary regulatory materials (CBDT, IRDAI, RBI, SEBI, Indian Kanoon). View our methodology.

Found an error? Report an issue.