Allahabad High Court sets aside ex-parte ESIC demand of Rs 1.45 crore on employer
The Allahabad High Court set aside an ex-parte ESIC order holding Continental India Private Limited liable for Rs 1.45 crore in unpaid contributions, and sent the case back for a fresh decision.
Key points
- The Allahabad High Court set aside an ex-parte ESIC order against Continental India Private Limited and a Meerut court order upholding it.
- The ESIC order of 7 July 2026 had held that the company had not deposited contributions of Rs 1,44,80,000.
- ESIC's Deputy Director at NOIDA must hear the company and decide again within one month of receiving the court's order.
The Allahabad High Court on 18 November 2026 set aside an ex-parte order of the Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC) that held Continental India Private Limited liable for unpaid contributions of Rs 1,44,80,000, about Rs 1.45 crore. The court sent the matter back to ESIC for a fresh decision after hearing the company.
What Happened
According to the judgment, ESIC began proceedings under Section 45A of the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948, which lets it assess contributions an employer owes, and passed an order on 7 July 2026 without hearing the company. The company challenged it under Section 75 of the Act and asked for a waiver of the deposit required to pursue that challenge. A civil judge in Meerut rejected the waiver request on 7 November 2026.
The company told the High Court that it had submitted the records ESIC asked for, as its correspondence of 8 June 2026 and 22 June 2026 showed. The court noted that on 22 June 2026 the company's representative was present but the ESIC officer appointed to verify the documents was absent. ESIC's counsel conceded that the documents had not been verified.
The court found that the 7 July 2026 order was passed without considering the company's documents and that a large liability had been assessed without any material on record. It set aside both the ESIC order and the Meerut court's order, and partly allowed the petition.
The court directed ESIC's Deputy Director at the sub-regional office in NOIDA to give the company a chance to submit all documents within one week, and to pass a fresh order in accordance with law within one month of receiving a certified copy of the judgment.
What It Means
The ruling reinforces that ESIC must consider an employer's records before assessing contributions under Section 45A, and that an order passed without doing so can be set aside. ESIC still has to decide the company's liability afresh, so the court has not ruled on how much, if anything, is owed. Employees covered by the ESI scheme are not affected by the order itself.
Source: High Court judgment
Sources & Citations
- High Court judgment — Allahabad High Court