OquiliaOquilia
Reviewed by·
InsuranceJournal

Car Insurance Explained: OD vs TP vs Comprehensive

11 min readShare

Car insurance in India combines two separate covers. Third-party (TP) cover pays for the owner's legal liability for harm caused to others; own-damage (OD) cover pays for damage to the owner's own car. A comprehensive policy is the two together. The structure decides what is legally required, what is optional and what a claim will pay.

Third-Party Cover: The Legal Requirement

Under section 146 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, a vehicle cannot be used in a public place without third-party insurance. TP cover pays for the owner's legal liability when the car causes death, injury or damage to property of other people: other drivers, pedestrians, cyclists and property owners.

TP cover pays nothing for damage to the owner's car. If the car hits a wall or a tree falls on it, the repair is not covered under TP.

The TP premium is not set by insurers. The base premium is notified by the central government under the Motor Vehicles (Third Party Insurance Base Premium and Liability) Rules, 2022, by engine capacity, so it is the same with every insurer. A new private car is sold with three years of TP cover.

Own-Damage Cover

OD cover pays for damage to the insured car from accidents, fire, theft, floods, storms, earthquakes, riots and damage in transit, subject to the policy's exclusions. If the car is stolen or written off, it pays the Insured Declared Value (IDV): the manufacturer's listed price less depreciation set by the car's age.

OD premiums are priced by each insurer and vary with the IDV, the city of registration, the make and model, the No Claim Bonus and the add-ons chosen. OD cover is not legally required. Owners whose TP cover runs separately, as on a new car, can buy OD cover on its own, from the same insurer or another.

Key Takeaway

TP cover is compulsory and its premium is set by the government, so it is the same everywhere. OD cover is optional, priced by each insurer, and is the only part that pays for damage to the owner's own car.

The Comprehensive Policy

A comprehensive policy bundles TP and OD cover. Car policies also carry a compulsory personal accident cover for the owner-driver, with a sum insured of Rs 15 lakh, which can be left out if the owner already holds such a cover.

Points to compare between policies:

  • IDV: the amount paid on theft or total loss, which also drives the OD premium.
  • Deductibles: a compulsory deductible is taken off every OD claim, Rs 1,000 for cars up to 1,500cc and Rs 2,000 above, plus any voluntary deductible chosen for a lower premium.
  • Depreciation on parts: on a standard OD claim, replaced parts are paid less depreciation: 50 percent on rubber, nylon and plastic parts, tyres, tubes and batteries, 30 percent on fibreglass parts, nil on glass, and a percentage on metal parts that rises with the car's age.
  • Add-ons and the claims process, including the insurer's network of cashless garages.

Common Add-Ons

  • Zero depreciation (nil depreciation): pays replaced parts without the depreciation deduction above. It usually carries a limit on the number of claims a year and an age limit for the car.
  • Engine protection: pays for engine damage from water entering the engine or oil leakage, which standard policies treat as consequential damage and exclude.
  • Return to invoice: on theft or total loss, pays the gap between the IDV and the original invoice value, usually including registration and road tax.
  • Roadside assistance: towing, a flat tyre, a battery jump-start and fuel delivery.
  • Key replacement: the cost of replacing lost or stolen keys, including reprogramming.
  • NCB protection: keeps the No Claim Bonus after a limited number of claims.
  • Consumables, personal belongings, tyre cover and daily allowance: narrower covers with their own limits.

Each add-on raises the premium; the policy schedule lists what has been bought and the wording sets the limits.

No Claim Bonus

The No Claim Bonus (NCB) is a discount on the OD premium for claim-free years:

  • After 1 claim-free year: 20 percent
  • After 2 years: 25 percent
  • After 3 years: 35 percent
  • After 4 years: 45 percent
  • After 5 years or more: 50 percent

A claim in a year sets the NCB back to nil at the next renewal. Example: with an OD premium of Rs 15,000 before NCB and an NCB of 50 percent, a claim raises the next premium from Rs 7,500 to Rs 15,000. Over the five renewals it takes to build the NCB back to 50 percent, the discounts given up add up to about Rs 18,750 at the same premium. Comparing that with the repair cost shows whether a small claim is worth making.

The NCB belongs to the policyholder, not the car. On selling a car and buying another of the same class, it moves to the new policy, and it moves with the policyholder to a new insurer at renewal. It is lost if the policy is not renewed within 90 days of expiry.

A lapse in cover, even for a day, leaves the car without the compulsory TP cover, and the insurer may ask to inspect the car before renewing OD cover. The NCB itself survives a gap of up to 90 days.

Older Cars

As a car ages its IDV falls, so the OD cover pays less on a total loss, while the premium does not fall at the same rate. Comparing the OD premium with the IDV each year shows how much cover the premium buys. TP cover remains compulsory whatever the car's age.

At Renewal

  • Renewing before expiry keeps the cover continuous and avoids an inspection.
  • OD premiums for the same cover differ between insurers, while the TP premium is the same everywhere.
  • A higher voluntary deductible lowers the OD premium but increases the share of every claim the owner pays.

The car insurance premium calculator estimates the OD and TP parts and the effect of NCB and add-ons.

Key Takeaway

A standard OD claim deducts depreciation on parts and a compulsory deductible; add-ons such as zero depreciation reduce those deductions for a higher premium. The NCB is lost only if renewal is more than 90 days late.

Explore Our Calculators

Run the numbers yourself with our 140+ financial calculators. SIP, EMI, tax, insurance, retirement — all in one place.

Discussion

Loading…
Loading discussion…

Stay in the loop

Monthly digest, no spam

One email a month with policy moves, deadlines, and the calculators readers used most.