Rent vs Buy Calculator: How the Comparison Works
The calculator adds up what buying costs and what renting costs, year by year, over the loan tenure. For buying it counts the down payment, stamp duty and registration, the EMIs and maintenance, takes off the tax benefit on home-loan interest, and then takes off the buyer's equity at that point: the property's value less the loan still owed. For renting it counts the rent paid, growing each year at the rate you enter. The break-even year is the first year in which the first total falls below the second.
What Counts as the Cost of Buying
- Down payment: The calculator starts at 20% of the price, and you can change it; lenders set their own loan-to-value limits. For an ₹80 lakh property, 20% is ₹16 lakh paid upfront.
- Stamp duty and registration: Each state sets its own; this calculator starts at 7% of the property value, and you can change it. In Mumbai, for a man, it is 6% stamp duty plus a registration fee capped at Rs 30,000: Rs 5,10,000 on an Rs 80 lakh property, a cost that is not recovered.
- EMI payments: On a ₹64 lakh loan (80% of ₹80 lakh) at an example rate of 8.5% for 20 years, the EMI is about ₹55,541 and the EMIs add up to about ₹1.33 crore.
- Maintenance: The calculator starts at 0.5% of the purchase price a year, and you can change it. Society charges and repairs vary by building.
- Property tax: Set by each municipality; the calculator leaves it out.
Against these costs the calculator sets the property's value, grown at the appreciation rate you enter. At an example 6% a year, a ₹80 lakh property is valued at 80,00,000 x 1.06^20 = about ₹2.57 crore after 20 years; at 3% it is about ₹1.44 crore. These are assumptions, not forecasts. Past price changes are measured by the Reserve Bank of India's House Price Index and the National Housing Bank's RESIDEX, and differ by city and locality.
What Counts as the Cost of Renting
- Rent growth: The rate is an input. As an example, ₹25,000 a month growing at 5% a year becomes 25,000 x 1.05^20 = about ₹66,332 a month after 20 years.
- No property at the end: The renter owns no property at the end of the period; the buyer owns the home, whose value the calculator subtracts from the cost of buying.
- Money not spent upfront: A renter does not pay the down payment and stamp duty. The calculator does not count what that money could earn. As an example only, ₹20 lakh growing at an assumed 12% a year becomes 20,00,000 x 1.12^20 = about ₹1.93 crore in 20 years; at an assumed 7% it becomes about ₹77.4 lakh.
Measures Used in the Comparison
- Price-to-rent ratio: The property price divided by a year's rent. A ₹1 crore flat renting for ₹25,000 a month (₹3 lakh a year) has a ratio of 33.3; its gross rental yield is 3,00,000 / 1,00,00,000 = 3% a year.
- Appreciation rate: The single input that moves the result most over a long tenure, because the property's value is subtracted from the cost of buying.
- Tax benefit: Under the old regime, section 22 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (old section 24(b)) allows home-loan interest of up to ₹2 lakh a year on a self-occupied home, and section 123 (old section 80C) counts principal repayment within its ₹1.5 lakh limit. At the 30% slab plus 4% cess, ₹3.5 lakh of deductions cut tax by 3,50,000 x 31.2% = ₹1,09,200. The new regime allows neither for a self-occupied home (section 202(2)(a)(v) and (xii)).
- Selling costs: Selling a home soon after buying adds brokerage and, on any gain, capital gains tax; the calculator does not model a sale.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which appreciation rate does the calculator use?
The one you enter. The calculator starts at 6% a year as an example, not a forecast. The RBI House Price Index and NHB RESIDEX publish past price changes by city.
Which rent growth rate does the calculator use?
The one you enter. The calculator starts at 5% a year as an example, not a forecast; a rent agreement may fix the yearly increase.
Does this calculator account for tax benefits?
It subtracts the tax saved on home-loan interest each year, at the rate you enter (30% to start with), on interest up to ₹2 lakh a year, the section 22 limit for a self-occupied home (old section 24(b)). Under the new regime there is no such deduction, so set the rate to 0. It leaves out the cess and the section 123 deduction on principal.
Disclaimer: This calculator gives a simplified comparison based on the assumptions entered. It leaves out location-specific factors, builder record, legal title and personal circumstances. It is not financial advice.