Endowment Plans vs Term Insurance Plus Mutual Funds: How the Comparison Works
An endowment plan combines life cover with savings under one policy: a single annual premium buys a death benefit during the term and a maturity benefit at the end. The alternative this calculator models splits the two: a pure term policy for the same life cover, with the rest of the premium invested in a mutual fund each year. The calculator compares the two on the figures you enter and shows the endowment plan's effective annual return (its internal rate of return, or IRR).
How Endowment Plans Work
A traditional (with-profits) endowment plan pays the sum assured on death during the term or on maturity, plus the bonuses the insurer declares. Reversionary bonuses are declared each year, usually as an amount per thousand of sum assured, and once declared are added to the policy. A terminal bonus, if any, is paid at maturity or on death. Bonuses are declared at the insurer's discretion; only the guaranteed benefits written into the policy are certain. The maturity value is the sum assured plus the accumulated reversionary bonuses plus any terminal bonus.
How the Calculator Works
Endowment side: the maturity value is the sum assured, plus a simple reversionary bonus at the rate you enter (a percentage of the sum assured for each year of the term), plus a terminal bonus as a percentage of the sum assured. The effective return is the IRR of paying the premium at the start of each year and receiving the maturity value at the end of the term.
Term plus mutual fund side: each year the calculator takes the endowment premium, deducts the term insurance premium you enter for the same cover, invests the rest at the start of the year and grows it at the return you assume. Mutual fund returns are not guaranteed and can be negative over some periods; the assumed rate is an input, not a forecast. The result is before tax on either side.
Worked Example
With the calculator's default inputs: an annual premium of Rs 1 lakh for 20 years, a sum assured of Rs 10 lakh, a reversionary bonus of 4.5% of the sum assured a year, a terminal bonus of 5% and a term premium of Rs 8,000. The endowment maturity value is Rs 19.5 lakh (Rs 10 lakh plus Rs 9 lakh of reversionary bonus plus Rs 50,000 of terminal bonus), against Rs 20 lakh of premiums paid, an effective return of -0.2% a year. On the other side, Rs 92,000 a year is invested; it grows to about Rs 74.2 lakh at an assumed 12% a year, Rs 58.0 lakh at 10% and Rs 45.5 lakh at 8%. A higher declared bonus or a lower assumed fund return narrows the gap, which is why the calculator lets you change both.
The Money-Back Plan Variant
Money-back plans pay part of the sum assured at set intervals during the term, with the rest plus bonuses at maturity. The payouts and the bonus basis are set in the policy. This calculator models a plan that pays only at maturity, so it does not cover a money-back schedule.
Tax
Under the old tax regime, life insurance premiums count towards the deduction the 1961 Act numbered 80C (section 123 of the Income-tax Act, 2025), which is capped at Rs 1,50,000 a year across all eligible items. The new regime under section 202 does not allow it. Maturity proceeds can be tax-free where the policy meets the conditions the Act sets on the premium relative to the sum assured; gains from a mutual fund are taxed as capital gains when units are sold. The calculator does not apply tax to either side.
Surrender and Paid-Up Value
Stopping an endowment plan early means taking its surrender value, which in the early years can be well below the premiums paid, or letting the policy continue as paid-up with a reduced sum assured. The policy's surrender value table and paid-up terms set both. The surrender line in this calculator's chart is a rough approximation (30% of the sum assured plus the bonus to date, from year three), not any insurer's table.
Calculating the Endowment IRR
The IRR is the annual rate that makes all the premiums paid equal in value to the maturity amount received. For example, a policy with a Rs 50,000 annual premium for 20 years and a maturity value of Rs 14.5 lakh (sum assured of Rs 5 lakh plus Rs 9.5 lakh of bonuses) has an IRR of about 3.4% a year on this calculator's method. The calculator works it out for the figures you enter, which can then be compared with the projections in the policy's benefit illustration.