ULIP vs Mutual Fund: How the Charges Change the Result
A unit-linked insurance plan (ULIP) is a life insurance policy whose premiums, after charges, are invested in funds chosen by the policyholder; it pays the fund value or the sum assured as the policy sets. A mutual fund invests money directly, with an expense ratio deducted from its value. This calculator invests the same amount each year in both at the same gross return and shows how the charges of each change the corpus.
Charges in a ULIP
A ULIP can carry a premium allocation charge deducted from each premium before it is invested, a mortality charge for the life cover, a fund management charge on the fund value, and policy administration, switching or discontinuance charges. The benefit illustration and the policy document set out the charges for the product. A mutual fund deducts its expense ratio from the fund value; direct plans have lower expense ratios than regular plans of the same scheme.
How the Calculator Works
Each year, the calculator deducts the premium allocation charge, invests the rest, grows the fund at the return entered, and then deducts the fund management charge and a flat yearly mortality charge. The allocation charge is the rate entered for policy years 1 to 5 and the second rate entered from year 6; the defaults of 5% and 2% are examples, and the policy's benefit illustration gives the real charges. No rule sets a yearly allocation charge: IRDAI's Master Circular on Life Insurance Products of 12 June 2024 limits ULIP charges through the yield instead. At a 4% gross yield, the illustrated fund value at maturity after all charges must be at least 90% of the premiums paid (para 7.15.1), and the benefit illustration must show the net yield, and so the reduction in yield, at the 8% gross return (para 54.7). For the mutual fund, the calculator invests the full amount, grows it at the same return and deducts the expense ratio. It does not work out tax.
With the example defaults (Rs 1 lakh a year for 15 years at 12%, an allocation charge of 5% in years 1 to 5 and 2% after, a Rs 3,000 mortality charge, a 1.35% fund management charge against a 0.5% expense ratio), the ULIP corpus is Rs 34.22 lakh and the mutual fund corpus Rs 39.72 lakh. The ULIP charges add up to Rs 3.80 lakh and the fund's expenses to Rs 1.21 lakh. After five years the two stand at Rs 6.29 lakh and Rs 7.00 lakh. The ULIP fund value does not catch up with the mutual fund within 15 or 30 years on these inputs; with other inputs the result differs. The mutual fund comparison does not include life cover, which the ULIP provides.
Lock-In, Withdrawal and Free Look
IRDAI's Master Circular on Life Insurance Products of 12 June 2024 (IRDAI/ACTL/MSTCIR/MISC/89/6/2024) sets a lock-in period of five years for linked insurance products, during which the policy proceeds are not paid out except on death or another covered event (Chapter 1, Section I, para 4). If premiums stop or the policy is surrendered during the lock-in, the fund value less the discontinuance charge goes to a discontinued policy fund and is paid out at the end of the lock-in (para 40.1). Partial withdrawals are allowed only after the lock-in (para 42.1), on the policy's terms. A life policy with a term of one year or more has a free-look period of 30 days from receipt of the policy, within which it can be returned; for a linked policy, the refund is made by repurchasing the units at the net asset value on the date of cancellation, less the proportionate risk premium, medical examination costs and stamp duty. Open-ended mutual fund schemes have no lock-in, except tax-saving ELSS schemes.
Tax Treatment for Tax Year 2026-27
Premiums. Under the old regime, a life insurance premium, including a ULIP premium, counts towards the Rs 1,50,000 deduction in section 123 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (the deduction the 1961 Act numbered 80C) under Schedule XV, paragraph 1(a), but only up to 10% of the actual capital sum assured for a policy issued on or after 1 April 2012 (15% for some policies covering a person with a disability or a specified illness). ELSS investments count under paragraph 1(m). The new regime in section 202 does not allow the deduction.
Maturity. Schedule II, Sl. No. 2 of the 2025 Act excludes a sum received under a life insurance policy from income, subject to conditions. For a ULIP issued on or after 1 February 2021, the premium must be within 10% of the sum assured (15% for a special policy) and the aggregate premium for all such ULIPs must not exceed Rs 2,50,000 in any tax year of their term; where these conditions are not met, the exclusion does not apply. The conditions do not apply to a sum received on the death of the insured.
Mutual funds. Long-term capital gains on equity-oriented fund units are taxed at 12.5% on gains above Rs 1,25,000 in a year under section 198(2), and short-term gains at 20% under section 196(1). This calculator does not apply either tax, so its corpus figures are before tax for both options.