Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) and Portfolio Management Services (PMS) are both regulated by SEBI, both have high minimums and both charge more than most mutual funds. They differ in who owns the investments, how the income is taxed, how fees are set and how easily money comes out. This guide sets the two side by side.
Portfolio Management Services
A portfolio manager registered with SEBI manages a separate portfolio for each client. A discretionary manager decides the trades and manages each client's money "in a manner which does not partake character of a Mutual Fund"; a non-discretionary manager acts on the client's directions (regulation 23(1), SEBI (Portfolio Managers) Regulations, 2020). The manager may not accept less than Rs 50 lakh in funds or securities from a client, a minimum that does not apply to an accredited investor (regulation 23(2)). Each client's securities are kept in separate accounts and the clients' money in a separate account with a scheduled commercial bank (regulation 23(4) and (5)). The client therefore owns the securities in the portfolio. The manager reports to the client at intervals agreed in the contract of no more than three months, showing holdings, transactions, income received and expenses (regulation 31(1)). SEBI has notified new Portfolio Managers Regulations, 2026, which take effect from 1 April 2027.
Alternative Investment Funds
An AIF is a pooled fund registered under the SEBI (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, 2012, usually set up as a trust, and the investor holds units in it. There are three categories (regulation 3(4)). Category I funds invest in start-ups, early-stage ventures, social ventures, SMEs, infrastructure or other areas the government or regulators consider socially or economically desirable. Category II is any fund not in Category I or III that does not borrow or use leverage beyond what the regulations permit, such as private equity and debt funds. Category III funds use diverse or complex trading strategies and may use leverage, including through derivatives. The minimum investment is Rs 1 crore, Rs 25 lakh for the fund's employees or directors, and none for accredited investors (regulation 10(c)). Category I and II funds are close-ended with a tenure of at least three years, extendable by up to two years with the approval of two-thirds of the investors by value (regulation 13); Category III funds may be open-ended or close-ended.
Tax
In a PMS, every purchase and sale in the portfolio is the client's own, so gains are taxed in the client's hands as if the client had traded: for listed equity in tax year 2026-27, 20% on short-term gains (section 196(1) of the Income-tax Act, 2025) and 12.5% on long-term gains above Rs 1,25,000 (section 198(2)). A portfolio with high turnover realises more short-term gains. Income of a Category I or II AIF, other than business income, is taxed in the investors' hands as if they had earned it directly (section 224), and the fund deducts 10% TDS on the income it pays out to residents (section 393(1), Table Sl. 4(iii)); business income is taxed at the fund level. Category III funds have no pass-through: the fund is taxed on its income according to how it is set up, so the investor's own tax rate does not apply to it.
Fees
A portfolio manager charges the fee agreed with the client, which may be fixed, return-based or a combination, with no up-front fee and no guaranteed or assured return; the range of fees is stated in the disclosure document (regulation 22(11) and (12)). An AIF charges a management fee and usually carried interest above a hurdle, as set out in its placement memorandum. How much a fee costs depends on the return. An illustration, ignoring GST and tax: on Rs 1 crore earning 15% before fees, a 2% fixed fee on the year-end value costs Rs 2.3 lakh and leaves 12.7%, while a 20% share of the return above a 10% hurdle costs Rs 1 lakh and leaves 14%. At 8% before fees, the fixed fee costs Rs 2.16 lakh and leaves 5.84%, and the performance fee costs nothing.
Liquidity
A PMS client can withdraw funds or securities before the end of the contract in the circumstances set out in regulation 24(2), on the terms in the agreement, which may include an exit charge. Money in a close-ended Category I or II AIF is usually locked in for the fund's life, which can run for years beyond the minimum three. Category III funds that are open-ended allow redemptions on the dates and notice periods in their documents. Illiquid holdings also limit how far the rest of a portfolio can be rebalanced; the portfolio rebalancing calculator works out the trades for the liquid part.
Comparing Returns
A portfolio manager must report performance on the same basis in its disclosures to SEBI, its marketing material, its reports to clients and its website (regulation 22(10)). Returns are comparable only when they are net of all fees, cover the same period and are measured against the same benchmark. For a close-ended AIF, money goes in and comes out at different dates, so its return is measured as an internal rate of return and as multiples of the money paid in, rather than as a simple annual figure. The AIF returns calculator models returns with carry and hurdle rates, and the IRR calculator works out a return from dated cash flows.
How the Two Differ
- Ownership: a PMS client owns the securities; an AIF investor owns units of a pooled fund.
- Minimum: Rs 50 lakh for PMS; Rs 1 crore for an AIF; neither applies to accredited investors.
- What they hold: PMS portfolios mostly hold securities; AIFs can hold unlisted companies, private credit, real estate and other assets, and Category III funds can use leverage.
- Tax: a PMS client is taxed on each trade; Category I and II AIFs pass most income through to investors; Category III funds are taxed at the fund level.
- Liquidity: a PMS allows withdrawal on the agreed terms; close-ended AIFs lock money in for the fund's life.
Checks Before Investing
The checks commonly made before investing in either: the manager's SEBI registration and regulatory history; audited returns across at least one full market cycle, including a falling market; every fee in writing, including hurdles, high-water marks and any clawback; how the portfolio is built and how risk is limited; key-person risk if the named manager leaves; and the exit terms, lock-in and notice periods. The HNI wealth management guide compares these products with mutual funds, and the HNI guide covers tax and succession.