Capital Budgeting Guide
The decision framework for evaluating corporate investments. Compare NPV, IRR, payback period and profitability index: the formulas, where the metrics agree and disagree, and common mistakes in the cash flows.
Net Present Value (NPV)
Value in rupeesFormula
NPV = SUM [CFt / (1+r)^t] - Initial Investment
Decision Rule: Accept if NPV > 0
Strengths
- Accounts for time value of money
- Measures absolute value creation in rupees
- Adds up across projects: the NPVs of independent projects can be summed
Limitations
- Requires accurate cost of capital estimate
- Absolute measure — does not show return efficiency
- Sensitive to discount rate assumptions
Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
Rate of returnFormula
The rate r that makes NPV = 0
Decision Rule: Accept if IRR > Hurdle Rate (WACC)
Strengths
- Intuitive percentage return
- Easy to compare across projects of different sizes
- Can be compared directly with the cost of capital
Limitations
- Can give multiple solutions for non-conventional cash flows
- Assumes reinvestment at IRR (not WACC)
- Misleading for mutually exclusive projects
Payback Period
LiquidityFormula
Years until cumulative cash flows = Initial Investment
Decision Rule: Accept if Payback < Target (e.g., 3 years)
Strengths
- Simple and intuitive
- Captures liquidity and risk aversion
- Useful as a first-pass screening tool
Limitations
- Ignores time value of money
- Ignores cash flows after payback
- The cut-off period is a choice, not derived from value
Profitability Index (PI)
Value per rupeeFormula
PI = PV of Future Cash Flows / Initial Investment
Decision Rule: Accept if PI > 1.0
Strengths
- Measures present value per rupee invested
- Used to rank projects when capital is limited
- Ranks projects by value created per rupee invested
Limitations
- Cannot handle mutually exclusive projects alone
- Less intuitive than NPV for non-finance audiences
- Ignores project scale
Which Metric to Prioritise?
| Scenario | Primary Metric | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Accept/reject a single project | NPV or IRR | Both give the same answer for conventional cash flows |
| Choose between mutually exclusive projects | NPV | IRR can give conflicting rankings; NPV measures absolute value |
| Limited capital budget, many projects | PI (then NPV) | PI ranks by value per rupee invested; maximise total NPV within budget |
| Quick screening / risk filter | Payback | Shows how soon the investment is recovered; ignores later cash flows and, in its simple form, the time value of money |
| Non-conventional cash flows (sign changes) | NPV or MIRR | IRR can have multiple solutions; MIRR resolves this by assuming reinvestment at WACC |
Five Common Capital Budgeting Mistakes
#1Using IRR for mutually exclusive projects
When only one of two projects can be chosen, the one with the higher IRR does not always add more value. A larger project with a lower IRR can have a higher NPV. Where IRR and NPV rank mutually exclusive projects differently, NPV measures the difference in value directly.
#2Ignoring opportunity cost of existing assets
If a project uses a factory floor the company already owns, the relevant cost is not zero: it is what the space could earn if it were let out or sold.
#3Confusing accounting profit with cash flow
Capital budgeting uses incremental cash flows, not accounting profit. Depreciation is not a cash expense and is added back (its tax saving is a cash flow). Interest is left out of project cash flows because the discount rate already allows for the cost of finance. Changes in working capital are cash flows that accounting profit does not show.
#4Counting sunk costs
Money already spent on a project does not change whether to continue it. The question is whether the future incremental cash flows justify the future incremental investment.
#5Using nominal cash flows with real discount rates (or vice versa)
Cash flows that include inflation are discounted at a nominal rate; cash flows in today's prices are discounted at a real rate. Mixing the two overstates or understates value, and the error grows with the inflation rate and the length of the project.
Capital Budgeting: The Science of Corporate Investment Decisions
Capital budgeting is how a company evaluates long-term investments: new plants, technology, acquisitions and products. The question in each case is whether the cash the investment brings in, allowing for when it arrives and how risky it is, is worth more than the cash it uses.
The Time Value of Money Foundation
A rupee today is worth more than a rupee later, even with no inflation, because a rupee today can be invested to earn a return. The discount rate is that opportunity cost of capital. Computing a project's NPV asks whether the project earns more than the next-best use of the same capital at the same risk.
NPV: Value Added in Rupees
NPV is the present value of the project's cash flows, at the cost of capital, less the investment. An NPV of Rs 50 crore means that, on the cash flows and the discount rate assumed, the project is worth Rs 50 crore more than it costs today. The NPVs of independent projects can be added together.
IRR: A Rate, Not an Amount
IRR is the discount rate that makes NPV zero. Comparing projects by IRR can mislead when they differ in size. Take two one-year projects and a 12% cost of capital: Rs 10 lakh invested returning Rs 13 lakh (IRR 30%) has an NPV of about Rs 1.61 lakh; Rs 10 crore invested returning Rs 12 crore (IRR 20%) has an NPV of about Rs 71.4 lakh. If only one can be chosen, the higher IRR points to the small project and the higher NPV to the large one.
Payback Period: A Measure of Liquidity, Not Profitability
The payback period is the time until cumulative cash flows recover the investment; the discounted payback period uses discounted cash flows. Neither looks at cash flows after the cut-off, so a project can pass the payback test and still have a negative NPV, or fail it with a positive one. Companies use it as a measure of how long capital is at risk.
Capital Rationing and the Profitability Index
When a company has more positive-NPV projects than capital, the profitability index, present value per rupee invested, ranks them. With Rs 100 crore to invest and five positive-NPV projects competing for it, choosing in order of PI until the budget is used tends to give the highest total NPV within the limit.
Real Options
A plain NPV treats a project as all or nothing. Many projects are staged, with the choice to expand, delay or stop as information arrives. Real options analysis values that flexibility: a staged research project can have a negative NPV if every stage must be funded, and a positive one once the option to stop after an early failure is counted.