Valuation Methods Guide
Four approaches to the question of what a business is worth: how each works, what it assumes and where it falls short, with a step-by-step DCF.
The Four Valuation Pillars
Discounted Cash Flow (DCF)
IntrinsicUsed for: Mature companies with predictable cash flows
Example: A company whose free cash flows can be projected from its revenue, margins and capital spending
Strengths
- First-principles approach
- Forces explicit assumption-making
- Not dependent on market sentiment
Limitations
- Highly sensitive to terminal value assumptions
- Requires detailed financial projections
- Less useful for pre-profit companies
Comparable Company Analysis
RelativeUsed for: Quick valuation benchmarking against listed peers
Example: A listed retailer valued on the EV/EBITDA multiples of other listed retailers
Strengths
- Market-informed and current
- Simple to execute
- Good for cross-checking DCF results
Limitations
- Assumes peers are fairly valued
- Sensitive to peer selection
- Ignores company-specific growth drivers
Precedent Transactions
RelativeUsed for: M&A valuation — what acquirers have paid for similar companies
Example: A cement company valued on the multiples paid in earlier acquisitions of cement assets
Strengths
- Captures control premium
- Reflects actual deal prices
- Used in pricing acquisitions
Limitations
- Deal terms are not always disclosed
- Transaction conditions vary
- Stale data if deals are old
Asset-Based Valuation
IntrinsicUsed for: Asset-heavy businesses, holding companies, liquidation analysis
Example: A holding company valued on the market value of the land and investments it owns
Strengths
- Based on assets that can be valued separately
- Provides valuation floor
- Works for holding companies
Limitations
- Ignores going-concern value and growth
- Difficult for intangible-heavy businesses
- Book values may not reflect market values
Step-by-Step DCF Walkthrough
Project Free Cash Flows
Build a 5-10 year projection of revenue, operating margins, capex, depreciation, working capital changes, and tax. FCF = EBIT(1-t) + D&A - CapEx - Delta WC.
Calculate WACC
Blend cost of equity (CAPM: Rf + Beta * ERP) and after-tax cost of debt, weighted by target capital structure. Each input is an estimate; the WACC calculator shows how the result moves with each.
Estimate Terminal Value
Use Gordon Growth (TV = FCF_n * (1+g) / (WACC-g)) or Exit Multiple method. The growth rate must be below WACC, and in perpetuity it cannot exceed the long-run growth of the economy.
Discount to Present Value
Discount each year's FCF and the terminal value by (1+WACC)^n. Sum = Enterprise Value.
Bridge to Equity Value
Equity Value = Enterprise Value - Net Debt + Non-Operating Assets - Minority Interests. Divide by shares outstanding for per-share value.
Mastering Business Valuation: A Complete Framework
Business valuation sits at the intersection of accounting, economics, and market psychology. Whether you are an investment banker advising on a merger, a fund manager deciding whether to buy a stock, or an entrepreneur raising a funding round, the question is the same: what are the future cash flows worth today?
Intrinsic vs Relative Valuation
The fundamental distinction in valuation is between intrinsic methods (which derive value from the company's own fundamentals) and relative methods (which derive value from how the market prices similar companies). DCF and asset-based valuation are intrinsic approaches; comparable companies and precedent transactions are relative approaches. Valuers commonly use more than one and present the results as a range.
Valuation in the Indian Context
The inputs differ by market. Indian rupee interest rates have generally been higher than US dollar rates, so a rupee DCF uses a higher risk-free rate, and the inflation built into rupee cash flows is different too. Cash flows and discount rate must be in the same currency, and multiples are compared with peers in the same market and sector.
Common Valuation Mistakes
The most frequent errors in valuation work include mixing currencies (projecting cash flows in rupees but using a dollar-based discount rate), double-counting growth (building growth into both the explicit period and the terminal value), ignoring dilution from outstanding ESOPs and convertible instruments, and applying P/E multiples without adjusting for one-time items that inflate or depress earnings.
When to Use Which Method
DCF depends on cash flows that can be projected, so it is most informative for companies with stable, positive cash flows. Comparable companies need listed peers and are quick to apply. Precedent transactions include the premium buyers paid for control, which is why they are used in pricing acquisitions. Asset-based valuation fits holding companies and businesses whose value lies mainly in land or investments.
The Art of Valuation Ranges
Valuations are usually presented as a range, showing the low end (conservative assumptions or asset-based floor), the mid-point (base case), and the high end (bull case with optimistic assumptions). In Indian equity research, the standard format is a target price with a bull, base and bear case. In M&A work the ranges from each method are often shown as a “football field chart” showing the overlap between different methodologies.
Valuation is both science and art. The science is in the formulas and frameworks; the art is in the assumptions. A DCF model is a structured way of expressing your view about a company's future. If the assumptions are wrong, the model will give a precise but incorrect answer, which is why the assumptions deserve more scrutiny than the arithmetic.