A SIP (systematic investment plan) invests a fixed amount at regular intervals. A lump sum invests the whole amount at once. Neither method changes the scheme's return; what differs is when the money is invested and so the NAV at which each rupee buys units. This article sets out the arithmetic and the trade-offs.
What Decides the Outcome
With a lump sum, the whole amount is exposed to the market from the first day. With a SIP, each instalment buys units at that day's NAV, so the average purchase price depends on the path the market takes during the instalment period. If prices rise steadily, money invested earlier buys more cheaply and the lump sum ends higher. If prices fall and then recover during the instalment period, later instalments buy more units at lower prices and the SIP can end higher. Which path the market will take is not known in advance.
For a salaried investor who saves from monthly income, there is often no lump sum to compare: the SIP follows from the timing of the income.
A Worked Example
At a constant assumed return of 10% a year (an assumption to show the arithmetic, not a forecast), Rs 12 lakh invested at once grows to Rs 31,12,491 in 10 years. A SIP of Rs 10,000 a month for the same 10 years also invests Rs 12 lakh in total, and grows to Rs 20,65,520. The gap arises only because the lump sum is invested for longer on average. With returns that vary from year to year, as real returns do, the result can differ either way. The SIP calculator and lumpsum calculator rerun this with your own figures.
Systematic Transfer Plans
An STP (systematic transfer plan) places a lump sum in one scheme, often a liquid or other debt fund, and moves a fixed amount into another scheme at set intervals. Each transfer is a redemption from the source scheme, so its exit load applies and each transfer is a sale for tax. Gains on units of a specified mutual fund bought on or after 1 April 2023 are taxed at the slab rate (section 76 of the Income-tax Act, 2025). The STP calculator shows the transfers.
Points to Compare
- Timing risk: a lump sum takes the market level of one day; a SIP spreads purchases over the instalment period.
- Cash flow: a SIP matches a monthly income; a lump sum needs the money in hand.
- Tax: each SIP instalment has its own purchase date and so its own holding period. For an equity-oriented fund, units held for more than 12 months give long-term gains (section 198) and the rest short-term gains (section 196).
- Costs: the expense ratio and exit load are the same for both methods.
The lumpsum vs SIP guide has more worked examples.